"Law Schools on the Brink of Drowning, 80% Bar Pass Rate Is the Bare Minimum Life Jacket"
Choipong Kyung, Chairman of the Law Professors Association
Low Pass Rate... Focus on Superficial Study
'Technicians of the Law' Rather Than Pursuing Justice
Commitment to Advanced Studies and Motivation to Retain Faculty
Need for Introduction of a 'Mandatory Elective Course Completion System'
Choi Bongkyung, Chairman of the Korean Law Professors Association (Professor at Seoul National University School of Law), is giving an interview to The Asia Business Daily. Photo by Dongju Yoon
View original image"Currently, law schools are on the verge of drowning. The proposal to raise the bar exam pass rate to 80% is the bare minimum life jacket to revive our broken legal education system."
Choipong Kyung, chairman of the Korean Law Professors Association and professor at Seoul National University School of Law, said this in an interview with The Asia Business Daily on April 8. He stated, "Due to the low pass rate, law schools have deteriorated to a point where they are even less effective than bar exam prep academies." He further pointed out that, "As students focus on superficial summaries aimed solely at passing the exam, rather than in-depth study of law, they are missing out on the profound and expansive world of legal scholarship. This unfortunate situation continues to persist."
Choi diagnosed the situation by saying, "While students ignore elective subjects that can be passed simply by attending a 'three-day special lecture' at an academy, numerous subjects such as human rights law, labor law, and environmental law are facing the risk of being discontinued." He continued, "It has been a long time since law schools hired professors for elective subjects such as international law or international business law, and even current professors worry every semester that their classes may be canceled, leading to a deep sense of insecurity and a significant drop in morale across the legal academia."
The breakdown of foundational legal studies is also a cause for concern. Choi explained, "As philosophy, the most essential discipline in all fields of study, is neglected, the foundation of legal scholarship is rapidly weakening." He noted, "In the past ten years, only one new professor of legal philosophy has been appointed at law schools nationwide."
According to Choi, such dysfunction in legal education could ultimately result in a lack of the 'Legal Mind,' which is the very foundation of the rule of law. He warned that legal professionals may become more focused on serving as 'technicians of the law' to achieve their personal objectives, rather than upholding justice.
Choi contrasted the situation with the national medical licensing exam, which has a pass rate exceeding 90%, and stressed, "Raising the pass rate is absolutely necessary for creating a predictable legal market and restoring normalcy to legal education." The association ran a simulation in which the pass rate is raised by 5 percentage points each year starting this year (the 15th exam), reaching 80% by 2031. The results showed that as the backlog of failed candidates is cleared, the annual number of new lawyers converges to around 1,800 from 2031, which is not much different from the current output.
He added, "The domestic legal market is worth about 10 trillion won, but the litigation market, where lawyers have traditionally concentrated, is only about 3 trillion won." He emphasized, "The remaining 7 trillion won market encompasses a vast array of areas, including corporate policy development and consulting, international legal services, and emerging blue ocean markets driven by artificial intelligence (AI)."
Choi repeatedly stressed the need to introduce a 'mandatory elective course completion system.' He explained that, instead of including electives in the bar exam, if these subjects are made a graduation requirement at universities, students could be freed from exam pressure to focus on advanced studies, while universities would have a reason to retain specialized faculty. He added that this would also ease the Ministry of Justice's burden of exam administration, making it a policy alternative in which all stakeholders in legal education can benefit.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
He said, "The root of the word 'law' is about burying personal interests beneath the ground to maintain neutrality." He concluded that it is the grave duty of our generation to reform the educational system so that legal professionals can walk the path of justice and fairness throughout their careers.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.