The Risk of Leaving, But No Reward
Why Prosecutors Hesitate to Be the First Penguin

[Law So-Si-Gae] Who Will Be the First Penguin at the SCIA? View original image

"Those who need a second chance will be the ones to go."


Prosecutor Section Chief A made this comment during a discussion about the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA). He suggested that those who have missed out on promotions or have been stuck in less desirable positions may try to make a 'career comeback' through the SCIA. Deputy Chief Prosecutor B, who has repeatedly faced demotion and been assigned to provincial posts, remarked, "For me, the SCIA is the only way out." Chief Prosecutor C speculated, "Someone at the level of Chief Prosecutor □□□ needs to head the SCIA for the organization to function; otherwise, it will fail," already fueling rumors about potential candidates.


Who will take the plunge? There is much debate among prosecutors over who will be the 'first penguin' at the SCIA. Of course, unlike prosecutors A, B, and C, prosecutor D takes a more optimistic view. He believes that having experience at the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office, Seoul Central District Prosecutors’ Office, Ministry of Justice, and the SCIA could serve as a valuable asset in the future law firm market. He argues that if even one prosecutor pioneers this route, juniors will likely follow the same path. In fact, law firms now say, "There’s no longer any reason to recruit prosecutors who remain at the Public Prosecution Office." Within the police as well, more and more new recruits are planning their careers to include experience at headquarters and the SCIA before moving to law firms. Experience with non-indictment powers and direct investigation authority comes with a premium in the law firm market.


Many in the legal community thus view the SCIA not as a 'public institution' but as a 'short-term investment in career experience.' With little incentive to join and endure the instability of a nascent organization, joining the SCIA could feel like a gamble. The prosecution's closed organizational culture also plays a role. For prosecutors who value seniority, unity, and a strong sense of group identity, joining the SCIA can initially be seen as 'defection.'


The problem is that the incentives included in the SCIA legislation are not attractive enough to draw such prosecutors. It is expected that investigative personnel will be unified as investigators and that a single-grade structure from levels 1 to 9 will be adopted. The 'Investigative Judicial Officer' system has been omitted. There are even concerns that, as an organization under the Ministry of the Interior and Safety, base salary and pension benefits could be lower.


The success or failure of the SCIA depends not on the system, but on the people. The question of who will be the first penguin is not just a matter of personnel. If the core members are those who view the SCIA as a short-term stepping stone for their careers, the organization's foundation will inevitably be shaky. If those seeking to build investigative expertise form the core, the agency will settle in successfully. Can the SCIA function well with only police personnel? One can make predictions by looking at the current state of police-led financial and corporate investigations. In the case of Bang Si-hyuk, Chairman of HYBE, the police conducted five rounds of questioning but, as of one year and four months later, have yet to reach a conclusion. The Coupang investigation task force mobilized a total of 86 members for the investigation, but after questioning interim representative Harold Rogers twice, no further action was taken. No one wants such investigative stagnation to be repeated in the SCIA.



The SCIA was launched under the banner of creating a Korean-style Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). It must be meticulously designed to ensure the system works as intended. If the SCIA falters and fails to perform its function, the same questions will inevitably arise once again: "The SCIA, the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials... Why were they created in the first place?"


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing