Most Cases Dismissed Due to "Failure to Meet Grounds for Complaint"

Since the implementation of the "trial complaint" system, which allows for constitutional complaints against court rulings, all 194 cases submitted during the three preliminary reviews have been dismissed.

View of the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View of the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On April 7, the Constitutional Court announced that, following deliberations by each designated panel of three Constitutional Court justices, all 120 trial complaint cases reviewed in the most recent preliminary screening were dismissed. Including 74 cases dismissed in the first and second rounds of preliminary review on March 24 and 31, a total of 194 trial complaint cases have been eliminated at the preliminary review stage. This represents 60.2% of the 322 trial complaint cases filed during the roughly one-month period since the introduction of the system up to the previous day. The remaining cases have yet to undergo preliminary review.


The dismissed cases on this day included a trial complaint submitted by attorney Jang Youngha, who was sentenced to prison for violating the Public Official Election Act after alleging that President Lee Jaemyung had ties to organized crime. Also included was a trial complaint filed by YouTuber Gu Jaeyeok (real name Lee Junhee), who was sentenced to three years in prison for extorting tens of millions of won by threatening YouTuber Tzuyang. The Constitutional Court determined that neither case met the grounds required for a trial complaint.


A trial complaint can only be filed if a court ruling is made in a manner contrary to a Constitutional Court decision, or if due process is not followed, thereby infringing on fundamental rights. When a case is filed, the designated panel evaluates whether it meets the legal requirements; if the petition is found inadmissible, it is dismissed without proceeding to a full hearing.



As in the previous two rounds, the most common reason for dismissal in this panel's review was failure to meet the "grounds for complaint" requirement, accounting for 77 cases. Other reasons included "expiration of the filing period" (30 cases), "other inadmissibility" (14 cases), and "lack of subsidiarity" (failure to exhaust all remedies under other laws) (4 cases).


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing