Kwanghoon Seok, Senior Expert at the Energy Transition Forum
"Support should shift from goods to people"
Petroleum consumption increases after implementation of price ceiling
Petroleum distributors report management difficulties
"LNG prices could surge starting in June"

Participants are taking a commemorative photo at the 'Emergency Discussion on the Middle East Energy Crisis Response: Demand Management and Renewable Energy Transition Tasks' held at the National Assembly on the 6th. Photo by Jihye Park's Office

Participants are taking a commemorative photo at the 'Emergency Discussion on the Middle East Energy Crisis Response: Demand Management and Renewable Energy Transition Tasks' held at the National Assembly on the 6th. Photo by Jihye Park's Office

View original image

Controversy is growing over the petroleum price ceiling system, which was implemented on March 13 and has now entered its fourth week. Critics argue that, contrary to its original purpose of easing the fuel cost burden on ordinary citizens, the policy is actually encouraging petroleum consumption and increasing the burden on national finances. Refiners and petroleum distributors are also voicing their difficulties. Meanwhile, there have even been calls from progressive circles, which are generally favorable toward the current administration, for the immediate abolition of the price ceiling system.


At the "Emergency Discussion on Response to Middle East Energy Crisis: Demand Management and Renewable Energy Transition Tasks" held at the National Assembly on the 6th, jointly organized by Better Future, the Energy Transition Forum, the Energy Citizen Coalition, and the Green Consumer Network in Korea, Kwanghoon Seok, Senior Expert at the Energy Transition Forum, who delivered the keynote presentation, pointed out, "Since the transportation sector accounts for 66% of domestic petroleum consumption, a major reduction in consumption in this sector is essential." He emphasized, "It is necessary to normalize petroleum prices so that they can properly fulfill their demand management function."


He further stated, "It is necessary to abolish the price ceiling system for petroleum products and restore the demand management function of petroleum prices through price liberalization, as implemented during the Kim Young-sam administration." Seok argued, "We need to shift to providing support for people, not petroleum prices," and called for the 5 trillion won in price ceiling subsidies allocated in the supplementary budget to be converted into disaster relief payments.


This means that the government should change its policy direction from providing subsidies for goods such as petroleum to offering direct support to people, and that the economic burden on ordinary citizens should be practically reduced through nationwide disaster relief payments.


In reality, as the government suppresses petroleum prices, petroleum consumption has actually increased. With international oil prices surging and wholesale prices being fixed for two-week intervals, consumers are stockpiling in advance in anticipation of future price hikes.


According to data submitted by the office of Assemblyman Ku Jagun of the People Power Party from the Korea Institute of Petroleum Management, gasoline sales at gas stations surged 24.7% from 257,423 kiloliters during the second week of March (March 9-15), when the first price ceiling was implemented, to 321,051 kiloliters in the fourth week. During the same period, diesel sales increased 16.3%, from 352,300 kiloliters to 409,949 kiloliters.


On March 27, the government announced a second round of petroleum price ceilings, raising the prices of gasoline and diesel by 210 won per liter compared to the first round. As a result, consumers now anticipate further price increases, creating an incentive to purchase before prices rise. The third round of petroleum prices is scheduled to be announced on April 9.


At the time of the system’s implementation, the Bank of Korea stated, "There is a positive effect in temporarily reducing the burden on consumers," but also warned, "The longer the policy is in place, the greater the risk of side effects such as excess demand." The Korea Institute for Industrial Economics & Trade also noted in a report that "price ceiling policies can cause excess demand and may also result in non-price allocation issues such as shortages, waiting lines, and price uniformity."


As fuel price controls persist, distributors are also expressing their difficulties. On the 6th, the Korea Petroleum Distributors Association stated, "Since the implementation of the price ceiling system, the supply prices from refiners to petroleum agents and direct supply prices to gas stations have become the same, forcing us to absorb losses without even covering basic distribution costs." The association insisted that supply prices for agents should be set lower than the price ceiling.


Domestically, petroleum products are produced by four major refiners—SK Energy, GS Caltex, S-Oil, and HD Hyundai Oilbank—who import crude oil, refine it, and then sell gasoline and diesel to petroleum agents or supply them to directly managed gas stations. Previously, petroleum agents purchased products in bulk at lower prices than gas stations and supplied them to gas stations. However, the introduction of the price ceiling system has disrupted this structure, causing difficulties for agents.


There are also concerns that if the U.S.-Iran war drags on, liquefied natural gas (LNG) prices could skyrocket starting in June.


Seok explained, "During the Russia-Ukraine war in 2022, a global gas supply disruption caused LNG prices in the EU to surge sixfold almost instantly. Based on this analysis of the current Middle East situation, if the worst-case scenario of a Hormuz Strait blockade occurs, the supply shock could far exceed that of the Russia-Ukraine war, potentially reaching up to ten times higher."


He warned, "Due to this massive supply shock, there is a high possibility that domestic LNG prices could surge uncontrollably starting this June."


LNG contributes to the burden of electricity and heating bills. Gas-fired power plants using LNG have the highest generation cost among major power sources. Korea Electric Power Corporation (KEPCO) purchases electricity from power generation companies and sells it to consumers, so if LNG prices soar, there is strong upward pressure on electricity rates.


However, if the government controls electricity rates, KEPCO's finances deteriorate. During the Russia-Ukraine war, the government restrained electricity rate increases, causing KEPCO’s cumulative debt to exceed 200 trillion won. As KEPCO’s borrowing grew, the domestic financial market became unstable.


At the discussion, there was also an in-depth discussion about the importance of expanding renewable energy and managing energy demand.


Byunghwa Han, Executive Director at Eugene Investment & Securities, emphasized, "To overcome the crisis, we must achieve our original plan to install 10GW of new renewable energy capacity by next year, one year ahead of schedule. To support this, we urgently need to secure a budget for building 10 to 20GWh of energy storage systems (ESS) and implement clear, timeline-based emergency measures."


Jeongseok Seo, Adjunct Professor at Hanyang University, stressed, "We must go beyond simply conserving energy and fundamentally transform the national industrial paradigm through real-time demand-side management (DSM) that combines AI and ESS, in order to maximize grid stability and renewable energy accessibility."


Changmin Park, Vice President of Gridwiz, said, "Demand response (DR) and virtual power plants (VPP) are the fastest and most economical means of defending against the current energy crisis. In addition to government R&D support, we urgently need institutional incentives that enable companies and citizens to actively participate in the energy flexibility market."


The discussion was attended by numerous National Assembly members, including co-hosts Assemblyman O Gi-hyung and Assemblywoman Ji-Hye Park, as well as Assembly members Im Mi-ae, Min Byung-deok, Kim Nam-geun, Jin Sung-jun, Heo Young, Kim Yun, Nam In-soon, Lee Yong-seon, Baek Hye-ryeon, and Jin Sun-mi.



Assemblyman O Gi-hyung, who heads Better Future, remarked, "The current energy crisis is a national emergency that threatens the Korean economy beyond international political instability." Assemblywoman Ji-Hye Park stated, "As the prolonged war has brought domestic energy conditions to a worrisome level, I hope that this gathering of civil society, industry, and the National Assembly will serve as a driving force to solve the issue of reducing energy demand."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing