Recommendation to Amend the Framework Act on the Status and Service of Military Personnel

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea has stated that even soldiers, who are obligated to obey orders, should be guaranteed a legally codified procedure to refuse or raise objections to orders that are clearly unlawful.


Soldiers attending the "Veteran Employment and Startup Expo" held last year in Seocho-gu, Seoul, are looking over job posting notices. This is not directly related to the article. Photo by Dongju Yoon

Soldiers attending the "Veteran Employment and Startup Expo" held last year in Seocho-gu, Seoul, are looking over job posting notices. This is not directly related to the article. Photo by Dongju Yoon

View original image

On April 6, the commission announced that the “Framework Act on the Status and Service of Military Personnel,” which stipulates the duty of obedience for soldiers, should be amended. While acknowledging the necessity of a hierarchical order and command system, the commission emphasized that, since soldiers are also subjects of constitutional fundamental rights, the scope of the duty of obedience should be limited to orders that comply with the law. Citing Supreme Court precedents, the commission noted that there is no duty to obey illegal orders.


The commission further pointed out the need to promptly amend the law to include education and training so that relevant response procedures can be practically exercised. In particular, it recommended incorporating education and training on the Constitution, the Framework Act on the Status and Service of Military Personnel, and the Martial Law Act in the early stages of officer training.



A representative from the commission stated, “It is necessary to improve the system to ensure harmony between the military command structure and the protection of soldiers’ fundamental rights,” adding, “We will continue to monitor for potential blind spots in human rights that may arise during military service.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing