[Grassroots Democracy in Crisis]②No Solution Yet for 'Gwangju Special City' Council... "61 South Jeolla Council Members + 23 Gwangju Council Members =?"
Risk of Constitutional Controversy if Councils Are Simply Merged
Special Parliamentary Committee Searching for Solutions
After the June 3 local elections, Gwangju Metropolitan City and South Jeolla Province will be integrated to form the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City (Gwangju Special City). This will be the first achievement of the 'Five Poles, Three Special Zones' national balanced development strategy under the Lee Jaemyung administration. However, there remains an unresolved issue: the method for composing the city council to provide checks and balances against the powerful 'Special Mayor' has yet to be determined.
According to the Special Committee on Political Reform of the National Assembly on April 5, discussions are underway regarding the composition of the Gwangju Special City council, but a solution has yet to be found. As of January this year, the population of Gwangju Metropolitan City was 1.39 million, and South Jeolla Province had 1.78 million. However, the number of metropolitan council members is 23 for Gwangju and 61 for South Jeolla. If the integration proceeds as is, the voting power of a Gwangju citizen (one representative per 60,000 people) would be less than half that of a South Jeolla citizen (one representative per 29,000 people).
In relation to this, Cho Kuk, leader of the Cho Kuk Innovation Party, previously stated, "If the elections are held under the current electoral district system, in the case of Gwangju Special City, all 12 Gwangju districts would exceed their population upper limit, while 11 South Jeolla districts would fall below the lower limit." He added, "According to the standards of the Constitutional Court, a total of 23 electoral districts would be 'unconstitutional districts'." Therefore, if Gwangju and South Jeolla are integrated as is, there is a risk that the new entity will immediately be embroiled in a constitutional controversy.
Within the Special Committee, several options are being considered to address this issue: 1) introducing a medium-to-large district system, 2) maintaining the existing metropolitan/provincial governor electoral districts, and 3) determining electoral districts by calculating the average population of the entire integrated municipality.
The National Election Commission is reportedly of the view that it would be reasonable to maintain the number of seats for South Jeolla while increasing the number of seats for Gwangju. In fact, a bill amending the Public Official Election Act has already been proposed in the National Assembly by Assemblyman Kim Moonsu of the Democratic Party to address the population disparity between Gwangju and South Jeolla. The bill would maintain the number of provincial council members in South Jeolla while doubling the number of city council members (metropolitan council members) in Gwangju. The National Election Commission is effectively supporting this proposal. Under this plan, Gwangju’s council members would increase from 23 to 46.
However, opposition voices have emerged from the People Power Party and others. They argue that the number of metropolitan council members would become excessively high compared to other regions. For example, Daegu, with a population of 2.35 million, has 33 city council members, and North Gyeongsang, with 2.5 million people, has 60 provincial council members. Assemblyman Kim Seungsoo of the People Power Party argued in the Special Committee, "When population is considered, Gwangju and South Jeolla already have more metropolitan council members. Increasing the number further through integration would only worsen the imbalance," expressing his opposition.
The introduction of a medium-to-large district system is also being discussed. In the face of the complex issue of integration between metropolitan governments, some propose using the current National Assembly electoral districts for metropolitan council elections to address the lack of proportional representation. Assemblywoman Lim Mi-ae of the Democratic Party, Assemblyman Jeong Chun-saeng of the Innovation Party, and Assemblywoman Jeong Hye-kyung of the Progressive Party have proposed a bill to use the current National Assembly electoral districts as metropolitan council districts and to elect 3 to 5 representatives per district under a medium-to-large constituency system.
Notably, this proposal explicitly includes "equivalence, proportionality, and diversity of composition" as its stated aims. The intent is to provide checks and balances on the expanded powers of the special mayor. In the past, the National Assembly Legislative Research Office noted in its report "Key Contents and Future Tasks of the Metropolitan Administrative Integration Special Act" that "while a head of the integrated government with strong authority will emerge, the functions to monitor and provide checks are relatively lacking." The report added, "It is necessary to strengthen the role of the local council to effectively monitor and check the executive branch of the integrated special city, and to promote the activation of resident participation systems."
In reality, during the local elections four years ago, the Gwangju City Council saw the Democratic Party win 22 out of 23 seats. The People Power Party, which had focused on establishing a foothold in the Honam region as the then ruling party, won only one proportional seat. In the South Jeolla Provincial Council, the Democratic Party won 56 out of 61 seats, while the Progressive Party, People Power Party, Justice Party, and independents each took one or two seats. As a result, a single party effectively controlled both the executive and legislative branches, making it difficult for checks and balances to function.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
However, the National Election Commission remains cautious about the introduction of a medium-to-large district system. The commission stated, "While it can be considered in the long term, introducing it immediately in the upcoming local elections would not be easy." Nevertheless, on April 3, the four progressive parties—the Democratic Party, Innovation Party, Progressive Party, Basic Income Party, and Social Democratic Party—reached an agreement to pass a political reform bill focused on strengthening proportional representation for metropolitan council members, raising the possibility of change. Still, adjustments in the number of seats will be inevitable during the integration process, and opposition from local political circles may become a variable.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.