[Exclusive] Local Politics Shaken by Regional Depopulation... Nine Metropolitan Council Districts at Risk of Being Ruled Unconstitutional [Grassroots Democracy in Crisis ①]
Nine Metropolitan Council Districts at Risk in Busan, Jeonbuk, and Gyeongbuk
Five Progressive Parties Including the Democratic Party Push to Pass Political Reform Bills by the 10th
In the June 3 local elections, electoral districts for metropolitan councilors (city and provincial council members) in certain basic local governments such as Busan, Jeonbuk, and Gyeongbuk are at risk of being ruled unconstitutional. While the National Assembly’s Special Committee on Political Reform is working to find a solution, with the ongoing crisis of regional depopulation, the current electoral system is increasingly losing its justification, making it necessary to consider more fundamental countermeasures.
According to the National Election Commission and the Ministry of the Interior and Safety on April 5, if the June 3 elections proceed under the current electoral system, there are as many as nine metropolitan council districts at risk of being ruled unconstitutional. These districts include not only areas such as Muju and Jangsu in Jeonbuk, Yeongyang and Ulleung in Gyeongbuk, and Uiryeong in Gyeongnam, but also Jung-gu in Busan, Gunwi-gun in Daegu, Ongjin-gun in Incheon, and Yeoncheon-gun in Gyeonggi Province.
On the last day of early voting for the 21st presidential election, May 30, a voter is casting their ballot at the early voting site located near Yonsei University and Ewha Womans University in Sinchon-dong, Seodaemun-gu, Seoul. 2025.5.30. Photo by Kang Jinhyung
View original imageThe current criteria for metropolitan council electoral districts stipulate that they can be determined within a range of plus or minus 50% from the average, which is calculated by dividing the metropolitan population by the number of metropolitan council members. For example, if there are 2 million people and 20 councilors, the average is 100,000 people per councilor, and basic local governments with 50,000 to 100,000 people can elect at least one metropolitan councilor. Additionally, the law states that basic local governments with fewer than 50,000 people must have at least one metropolitan councilor, while those with 50,000 or more must have at least two.
The problem is that, due to population decline, some districts no longer meet these criteria. Last October, the Constitutional Court ruled on the permissible population deviation for city and provincial council districts. The Court found that the Jangsu-gun district in Jeonbuk fell below the minimum population threshold for the region, and ruled that this violated the constitutional value of "equality of voting rights according to the principle of proportionality to population."
In fact, as of October last year, all nine districts in question had populations below the average for their respective metropolitan councils, though to varying degrees. For instance, in Jung-gu, Busan, the city council minimum is 38,683 people, but the actual population is 36,783. In Ulleung-gun, Gyeongbuk, the situation is even more severe: the average population per Gyeongbuk provincial council member is 69,823, but Ulleung-gun's population is only 8,766.
Currently, the Special Committee on Political Reform is seeking ways to address the constitutional issue. One approach under consideration, according to the Public Official Election Act, is to use a 20% adjustment range in councilor numbers, essentially increasing the number of councilors to lower the average population per councilor. According to the National Election Commission and others, if the number of councilors is increased (so-called "adjustment"), a solution could be found for districts such as Jung-gu in Busan and Muju-gun in Jeonbuk, as there is room to increase councilor numbers in Busan and Jeonbuk. However, for the remaining seven districts, it would be necessary to combine regions. There is also a proposal under discussion in the Special Committee to expand the adjustment range to 30% in order to secure even more councilor seats.
Other approaches being considered include raising the representativeness of basic local governments through legislative measures, or merging adjacent regions to hold joint elections. There are also suggestions to reflect the special nature of islands such as Ulleungdo or Ongjin-gun through legislation.
The issue, however, is that these methods are only temporary. No matter how much councilor numbers are increased or regions are merged, these are only stopgap measures in the face of ongoing regional depopulation, and have their limits. Even legislative approaches to enhance the representativeness of basic local governments may be at odds with the Constitutional Court’s judgment, raising the possibility of further constitutional disputes.
For these reasons, introducing multi-member district systems is now being discussed as an alternative. The National Assembly Research Service stated in a report, "In the medium and long term, it is necessary to review and supplement the principles and procedures for district delimitation and adjustment so that deviations from standards do not repeatedly occur even as demographic changes continue."
The issue is time. Because the Special Committee on Political Reform began its work so late, there is little time to prepare for system reform. The National Election Commission believes that all election-related laws must be finalized by the 17th. The timeline is tight: promulgation of the law on the 22nd, submission of basic council district delimitation plans to city and provincial councils on the 24th, and implementation of amended district delimitation ordinances on the 1st of the following month. These deadlines are the "last line of defense."
The National Election Commission is also taking a passive stance for these reasons. An official from the Special Committee said, "While it is possible to consider this in the long term, it will be difficult to introduce such changes for this local election." Within the committee, some are calling for pilot programs, taking into account the practical realities.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
However, there is a new variable: on the 2nd, the Democratic Party of Korea, the Rebuilding Korea Party, the Progressive Party, the Basic Income Party, and the Social Democratic Party—the five parties with seats in the National Assembly—agreed to expand the use of multi-member districts and increase the proportion of proportional representation in local councils for the June 3 local elections as part of political reform. These parties announced an agreement to pilot the introduction of multi-member districts in metropolitan council elections, and to raise the proportion of proportional representation councilors above the current 10%. While the possibility of electoral system reform has increased, uncertainty remains. Because this is a matter of the "rules of the game" for elections, the Special Committee is seeking bipartisan agreement, and it remains to be seen whether the People Power Party will support the change. The Democratic Party and others have also stated their intention to complete the relevant legislation by the 10th.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.