Smilegate, a game company that lost a civil lawsuit worth approximately 100 billion won related to its initial public offering (IPO) with Rhinos Asset Management, has announced plans to appeal the decision.


Smilegate logo. Provided by Smilegate

Smilegate logo. Provided by Smilegate

View original image

A representative from Smilegate stated on April 2, "We plan to appeal this verdict," adding, "We will review the ruling in detail and proceed with the necessary procedures after preparing accordingly." The representative also explained, "The reason we reclassified the convertible bonds (CB), which were previously considered equity, as liabilities was to comply with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) during IPO preparations. This was not an arbitrary decision, but was made through an accounting firm designated by the court."


On April 2, the 31st Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Nam Insu) ruled in favor of Rhinos Asset Management in a lawsuit filed against Smilegate Holdings for damages and sales proceeds, ordering Smilegate to pay the plaintiff 100 billion won and annual interest of 12% calculated from December 2023. Rhinos Asset Management had filed the damages claim against Smilegate Holdings in November 2023.


This dispute began when Rhinos Asset Management purchased convertible bonds worth around 20 billion won from Smilegate in 2017. According to the contract, Smilegate agreed to pursue an IPO if the company posted net profit exceeding 12 billion won in the previous fiscal year. After the success of Smilegate’s massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) "Lost Ark" led to a significant increase in performance, Rhinos Asset Management demanded an IPO in 2022.



However, Smilegate argued that, in preparation for the IPO, it adopted IFRS and reclassified the CBs—previously recognized as equity under general accounting standards in 2021—as liabilities, resulting in a net loss of 142.6 billion won and thereby nullifying its IPO obligations. The court stated, "If the company's claim is accepted, the better the performance and the higher the net profit, the more IPO obligations would be triggered. But if the conversion rights are assessed as liabilities and recognized as a loss at this stage, it would create a circular logic where the IPO obligation disappears as a result."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing