SME Technology Transfer Project Designated as a Key National Agenda
Delay in Reauthorization of U.S. Benchmark Programs
Need to Strengthen National Security and Technology Protection Systems in Korea

As South Korea intensifies efforts to promote technology transfer projects for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and foster defense startups, experts have called for a comprehensive review of related national policies, particularly in light of delays in the reauthorization of the U.S. Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) programs.


On April 2, the Small and Medium Venture Business Research Institute released a report entitled "Implications of Delayed Reauthorization of U.S. Small Business Innovation Support Programs: Focusing on SBIR and STTR."


SBIR Phase-by-Phase Support. Small and Medium Business Venture Research Institute

SBIR Phase-by-Phase Support. Small and Medium Business Venture Research Institute

View original image

Kang Jaewon, a research fellow at the institute, stated, "The government is advancing a Korean-style SME technology transfer initiative, modeled after the U.S. Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR), as a key national agenda, and is also expanding policies to foster defense startups. Given this, the delay in reauthorizing the U.S. Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) programs should not be seen merely as a legislative gap, but as an opportunity to thoroughly review the overall operation of these systems."


He added, "Since the expiration of their authority in September last year, the SBIR and STTR programs have experienced delays in announcements, cancellations of selections, and withdrawals of support due to the reauthorization delay. However, with an alternative bill passing both the House and Senate in March, the programs are set to resume."


The report explained that three key issues emerged during the U.S. SBIR and STTR reauthorization process. The first was national security and technology protection. The United States assessed that risks of core technology leakage were increasing due to direct and indirect investments by foreign governments, the provision of subsidies, technology transfer, and recruitment of key personnel. As a result, eligibility and risk assessment programs have been strengthened, reviewing applicants’ cybersecurity, patent transfers, foreign partnerships, and corporate governance. However, some in Congress have pointed out that actual on-the-ground responses remain insufficient.


The issue of support being concentrated among a small number of companies was also raised. From 2011 to 2020, only 22 companies (0.34%) received support more than 50 times in Phase II, but these companies accounted for 11% of the total number of awards and 10% of the total funding. Despite this concentrated support, the sales, private investment, and patent performance of these beneficiary companies lagged behind those of comparable companies.


There are also concerns about the effectiveness of commercialization support mechanisms. Although federal agencies administering the Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) program are required to implement the Commercialization Assistance Pilot Program (CAPP), most agencies, except for the Department of Energy, have not actually done so. Kang emphasized, "Legal institutionalization alone is not enough; it must be accompanied by ongoing monitoring and oversight to ensure the process continues through to the commercialization stage."


Mandatory Ratio and Support Performance of Technology Innovation Support Projects for Korean Small and Medium Enterprises. Korea Institute of Startup & Entrepreneurship Development

Mandatory Ratio and Support Performance of Technology Innovation Support Projects for Korean Small and Medium Enterprises. Korea Institute of Startup & Entrepreneurship Development

View original image

With regard to the operational framework of Korea’s Small and Medium Business Innovation Support Program (KOSBIR), there are calls to strengthen the technology protection system from the perspective of national security and competitiveness. As exports of Korean-made weapons expand, the likelihood of foreign intelligence agencies attempting to steal related technologies is also increasing. The report highlighted the need to review monitoring systems to prevent the leakage of critical technologies during SME-led R&D projects, and suggested that, alongside the expansion of defense industry startup support and private-investment-led technology startup programs (TIPS), security-oriented management standards for foreign investments should also be considered.


The report also recommended that the current management system for the Small and Medium Business Innovation Support Program (KOSBIR) should shift from focusing on mandatory ratio compliance to a management approach centered on commercialization outcomes. Currently, performance management is limited to checking actual support results against mandatory ratios, with insufficient analysis from the perspective of commercialization. The report further pointed out that it is necessary to strengthen oversight of overlapping and concentrated support at the inter-ministerial level.



Kang added, "South Korea should also review the operational framework of its Small and Medium Business Innovation Support Program (KOSBIR) from a security perspective and incorporate the institutional limitations revealed during the U.S. reauthorization delays to establish a more effective Korean-style technology innovation support system. As such security-oriented review systems are introduced and strengthened, it will also be necessary to consider how to alleviate the increased burden on SMEs."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing