Supreme Court Dismisses Defendant’s Appeal

An elementary school teacher who killed an 8-year-old girl with a weapon at an elementary school in Daejeon has had her life sentence confirmed by the Supreme Court.

Myung Jaewan, who killed an elementary school student with a weapon at the elementary school where he worked. Daejeon Police Agency

Myung Jaewan, who killed an elementary school student with a weapon at the elementary school where he worked. Daejeon Police Agency

View original image

The first division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Seo Kyunghwan) on the morning of April 2 upheld the lower court’s life imprisonment sentence for Myung Jaewan (48, female), who was indicted and detained on charges of violating the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes (for-profit abduction and enticement, etc.), damage to public property, and assault.


On February 10 last year, around 5 p.m., Myung lured the victim, who was heading home after an after-school care class at the elementary school where she worked, into the audiovisual room by saying she would give her a book, and then stabbed and killed Kim with a weapon she had prepared in advance. She was also charged with kicking and damaging a school work computer and assaulting a fellow teacher before committing the crime.


The prosecution demanded the death penalty, but Myung’s defense admitted the charges while claiming diminished responsibility due to mental illness, including depression. She was reportedly suffering from severe separation anxiety, a sense of alienation from her family, difficulties adapting at work, and regret over an early return from medical leave. At the time of the crime, she had just returned to work on February 3 after taking medical leave for depression treatment.


The court of first instance sentenced Myung to life imprisonment, stating it was difficult to find that her ability to distinguish right from wrong or control her actions was absent or diminished at the time of the crime. Even if she had been in a diminished mental state, the court found that, considering the brutality of the crime, a reduction of the sentence was not warranted.


The appellate court also did not recognize diminished responsibility. The court noted, "Myung committed assault and damage to public property before the crime, and it appears she was fully aware of both the circumstances under which she committed the crime and the wrongfulness of her actions." The appellate court maintained the lower court’s sentence, finding that it did not fall outside the reasonable scope of judicial discretion.



The Supreme Court likewise rejected the claim of diminished responsibility. The court explained, "Considering that the crime was premeditated, that she took actions to conceal the crime, and that she gave detailed testimony about the process, it cannot be regarded that the defendant was in a state of diminished responsibility at the time of the crime."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing