Loss of Opportunity for Debt Reduction... Equivalent to Issuing Government Bonds

Tax Revenue Re-Estimates Are Only Forecasts... Concerns Over Shortfall in Second Half

Bank of Korea’s 3.4 Trillion Won Surplus Not Included, Violating the Princ

The National Assembly Budget Office has raised questions about the government's explanation of the "war-related supplementary budget" as a "supplementary budget without government bond issuance." The office pointed out that since the excess tax revenue—which should have been used for repaying government bonds—is being allocated to the supplementary budget, the fiscal impact is similar to that of issuing additional government bonds.


On April 2, the National Assembly Budget Office, in its report analyzing the "1st Supplementary Budget Bill," highlighted, "The costs associated with formulating a supplementary budget exist regardless of whether additional government bonds are issued." The office further explained, "If a supplementary budget were not created, the excess tax revenue would remain as a surplus and, according to Article 90 of the National Finance Act, at least 51% or more would have been mandatorily used for debt reduction, such as repaying the principal and interest of government bonds. In effect, using the entire excess tax revenue for expenditure and thereby losing this debt reduction opportunity has a fiscal impact substantially similar to directly issuing additional government bonds, particularly in terms of fiscal soundness."


Questions were also raised about the government's economic response in the second half of the year. The office noted, "The tax revenue forecast revised in March is only an estimate, and depending on the economic trend in the second half as well as the scale and duration of the fuel tax cut, there is a possibility of a tax revenue shortfall." It continued, "Should the tax revenue environment deteriorate in the second half due to factors such as the prolonged Middle East crisis, the projected revenue adjustment may not be realized, potentially causing disruptions in fiscal management."


Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Strategy and Finance Koo Yun-cheol is reporting to President Lee Jae-myung on the emergency national operations and response status related to the Middle East war at the Cabinet meeting held at the Blue House on the 31st. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Strategy and Finance Koo Yun-cheol is reporting to President Lee Jae-myung on the emergency national operations and response status related to the Middle East war at the Cabinet meeting held at the Blue House on the 31st. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

There was also criticism regarding the repeated inaccuracies in tax revenue forecasts. An official from the budget office stated, "Both underestimation and overestimation of tax revenue lead to inefficiencies in fiscal management and unnecessary administrative costs. The current case, in which a tax revenue error of about 25 trillion won occurred only three months after the start of the fiscal year, suggests that the issue goes beyond a simple forecasting failure and indicates a need for the fiscal authorities to review the entire tax forecasting system." According to the analysis, while the net increase in tax revenue amounted to 25.2 trillion won, the total absolute value of errors by tax item included in the official revenue adjustment amounted to 34.6 trillion won.


The office also took issue with the fact that 3.4 trillion won in excess remittances from the Bank of Korea’s surplus were not included in the revenue for this supplementary budget. This, it emphasized, is different from past supplementary budgets where such surpluses were reflected. The office stated, "Not utilizing the Bank of Korea’s surplus funds in the supplementary budget does not align with the budget totalization principle of the National Finance Act." It added, "During the National Assembly’s deliberation process, the government should present all available financial resources and allow the National Assembly to review and decide on their use."



Meanwhile, the budget office predicted that the implementation of this supplementary budget would raise this year's economic growth rate by 0.21 to 0.29 percentage points. It noted that the more the budget is executed in the first half of the year, the greater the economic growth effect will be.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing