There are criticisms from legal experts and others that Hanwha Solutions’ paid-in capital increase, amounting to approximately 2.4 trillion won, goes against the intent of the revised Commercial Act. While it may not be outright illegal, critics argue that the decision does little to protect the rights and interests of general shareholders.


Hanwha Solutions CI.

Hanwha Solutions CI.

View original image

Hanwha Solutions announced the paid-in capital increase just two days after its regular shareholders’ meeting on March 24. The method chosen is an allocation to existing shareholders followed by a public offering of forfeited shares. The new issuance will add 72 million shares, which is about 42% of the existing issued shares. Of the funds raised, approximately 1.5 trillion won will be used for debt repayment and about 900 billion won for facility investment.


Experts in corporate law say it would be difficult to challenge Hanwha Solutions’ paid-in capital increase in court. This is because: △Under the Commercial Act, in principle, the board of directors rather than the shareholders’ meeting decides on paid-in capital increases; △It is not problematic for a company to seek a capital increase to repay debts or secure investment funds; △The paid-in capital increase is allocated to shareholders, allowing general shareholders to participate as well.


However, these experts also assessed that while the capital increase may not be illegal, it is at odds with the shareholder protection intent emphasized in the revised Commercial Act. Junbeom Cheon, CEO of WiseForest and a corporate strategy advisor (Judicial Research and Training Institute, Class 35), cited Article 382-3, Paragraph 2 of the amended Commercial Act. This provision states, “A director must protect the interests of all shareholders when performing their duties and must treat the interests of all shareholders fairly.” Cheon said, “Under the revised Commercial Act, when a company asks shareholders for additional contributions such as a paid-in capital increase, it must explain the necessity. I believe Hanwha Solutions’ lack of communication has led to shareholder backlash.”


Kwangjoong Kim (Class 36), an attorney at ClassHankyeol Law Firm, said, “It is difficult to definitively say that this paid-in capital increase violates the revised Commercial Act,” but added, “When deciding on a capital increase, the company should carefully analyze not only the scale and timing but also whether there are alternative means of raising funds. I wonder whether the newly appointed directors at Hanwha Solutions could have adequately reviewed the capital increase in consideration of the revised Commercial Act, given the time constraints.” At the March 24 shareholders’ meeting, Hanwha Solutions newly appointed two outside directors. Dongkwan Kim, Vice Chairman of Hanwha Group, and Jungwoon Nam, Head of the Chemical Division of Hanwha Solutions, were reappointed as directors.


An attorney at a major law firm commented, “It is not a case where Hanwha Solutions can be definitively said to have infringed on shareholder rights. However, it is open to criticism that the capital increase is focused on major shareholders.”


The controversy surrounding Hanwha Solutions’ paid-in capital increase continues. ACT, a minority shareholder platform, has submitted a petition to the Financial Supervisory Service, urging a thorough review of the capital increase. Lee Sangmok, CEO of ACT, said, “We are considering sending a shareholder letter to Hanwha Solutions and plan to select a shareholder representative to deliver our message.” He also stated that Hanwha Solutions’ capital increase not only involved improper methods but also damaged trust in the stock market.


The Korea Corporate Governance Forum (KCGF), which has advocated for capital market reform, also issued a statement criticizing Hanwha Solutions’ capital increase. KCGF said, “While we understand the need for fundraising due to Hanwha Solutions’ deteriorating financial structure, the company did not consider the interests of general shareholders. This was a surprise disclosure similar to what happened with Hanwha Aerospace.”


Hanwha Solutions, on the other hand, maintains that the capital increase is unavoidable. The company cites that its total consolidated borrowings are expected to reach about 15 trillion won in 2025, and its capacity to implement self-rescue measures is limited.



Reporter Sangwoo Lee, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing