The Temptation of Collusion Runs Deep Throughout Human Trade History
Breaking the Cycle: Losses from Collusion Must Outweigh Expected Gains
Stronger and More Comprehensive Regulations Needed to Tackle Collusion

[The Editors' Verdict] The Immortality of Collusion View original image

Last month, the Fair Trade Commission uncovered a price-fixing scheme involving pork. Following similar cases with sugar, flour, and starch syrup, companies colluded to manipulate the price of pork belly, a staple on the tables of ordinary people. By now, such revelations are hardly surprising.


Collusion has deep historical roots. Records indicate that around 3000 BC, Egyptian merchants conspired to inflate wool prices, marking what is considered the earliest known case of collusion in human history. In medieval Europe, guilds—merchant organizations established to protect the interests of specific industries—controlled prices and supply. In the 19th century United States, industrial tycoons such as Rockefeller and Carnegie were caught exploiting their monopolies to raise the price of goods and reap exorbitant profits.


In Korea, the so-called “Sambun (Three Powders) Incident” of 1963 became widely known, where a handful of major companies monopolized the sugar, flour, and cement markets and colluded to fix prices. At the time, more than ten flour manufacturers colluded to raise prices up to three times the official price, reaping illicit profits exceeding 10 billion won. This triggered discussions that eventually led to the enactment of the Fair Trade Act, which strictly prohibits collusion.


However, collusion among flour manufacturers continued. In 2006, eight milling companies were fined a total of 43.4 billion won for colluding on the price and supply of flour. Earlier this year, a 6 trillion won flour price-fixing scheme involving seven of these companies was uncovered.


Collusion undermines competition, which is at the heart of a market economy, and consumers ultimately bear the brunt of the damage. In particular, price-fixing of essential food items drives up grocery prices and places a greater burden on vulnerable groups, making it a malign element in the economy for ordinary people. Yet, because collusion is carried out covertly among involved parties, detection is difficult. Even when caught, the profits companies gain from collusion often outweigh the penalties, making it hard for businesses to resist the temptation.


For example, in 2019, Harim Group’s holding company, Harim Holdings, was fined 18 million won for a collusion scheme involving breeding stock (parent chickens for breeding). In 2022, a broiler price-fixing case was uncovered, resulting in a total of about 100 billion won in fines for Harim Holdings and its affiliates Harim, Allforyou, and Hangang Food. In the recently uncovered pork price-fixing case, Harim Group’s livestock affiliates, Sunjin and Haedream LPC, were also implicated.


The Fair Trade Commission found that nine meat processing companies supplying pork to Emart colluded by agreeing on a price floor before submitting their bids. Notably, in the case of branded pork, the companies coordinated their estimates in advance on ten separate occasions from July 2021 to October 2023. This continued even after Harim affiliates were caught in a broiler price-fixing case.


According to the Fair Trade Commission, the scale of collusion in the supply of general pork to Emart was 10.3 billion won, while that for branded pork was 8.7 billion won. By securing the participants’ Telegram messages via the leniency program (self-reporting for reduced penalties), the commission was able to uncover the full extent of the scheme. Sunjin’s sales last year totaled 543.8 billion won, with only 11.82% coming from retail outlets. The remainder was overwhelmingly from wholesale distribution (35.49%) and carcass sales (45.82%). This suggests that the amount of pork price-fixing uncovered this time may be just the “tip of the iceberg.” The total fines imposed for pork price-fixing were 3.1 billion won, and through the leniency program, Sunjin, Haedream, and Farm Story were excluded from prosecution.



Repeated collusion should not simply be dismissed as the misconduct of a few unethical companies. It is a structural problem that arises from the combination of capital’s drive to maximize profits and the uncertainties of the market. Only when the expected economic losses from collusion exceed the profits gained will companies be able to break free from the lure of price-fixing.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing