[Reporter’s Notebook] A String of Court Defeats... People Power Party Shoots Itself in the Foot View original image

"People Power Party? Even people in Busan don't trust them anymore. They should be more inclusive and embrace people. If they keep pushing out anyone who speaks the truth and run things in a dictatorial manner, what do they expect will happen?"


This is how a citizen in his 70s, whom I met in Busan—a traditional stronghold of conservatives—described the local sentiment. With the 9th nationwide local elections set for June 3, 2026, voters in Busan are already sending a warning message. The opposition party is failing to act like a true opposition, and is instead wasting time on internal power struggles, making it difficult for voters to give them their support.


Recently, the People Power Party has experienced a series of defeats in legal disputes related to internal party matters, damaging its reputation. Although issues like disciplinary actions and candidate nominations may appear different, they are ultimately linked to the party's power struggles. Following disciplinary actions against former Supreme Council member Kim Jonghyuk and Seoul Metropolitan Party Chairwoman Bae Hyunjin, as well as the exclusion (cutoff) of Chungcheongbuk-do Governor Kim Younghwan from nomination, the court has accepted injunctions to suspend these decisions. This indicates that the party's disciplinary and nomination processes have not been fair.


The reason the judiciary generally refrains from intervening in internal party affairs is that the Korean Constitution guarantees broad autonomy in the organization, operation, and candidate selection processes of political parties. Nevertheless, the People Power Party has repeatedly been halted by court decisions.


While the People Power Party protests these as "biased decisions," it may be worth reflecting on why the court had to make such rulings in the first place. This suggests that the party's internal decision-making has strayed so far from democratic legitimacy that it exceeds the autonomy guaranteed by the Constitution.


The root of the problem lies in the leadership's attitude. Rather than persuasion and inclusion, the leadership has tried to resolve issues through what amounts to a "political purge." This approach inevitably leads to ongoing disturbances. The party's Ethics Committee invited criticism by justifying disciplinary action with the claim that "the party leader represents the collective free will of the members."


Some have even called this a sophistry intended to suppress political criticism. The case of Governor Kim is not much different. The justification for his exclusion from nomination was "party before self," but the court ruled that it was an exclusion without clear criteria. The lack of reasonable grounds and procedures has undermined the legitimacy of the cutoff.


An even greater problem is time. The local elections are now only two months away. These elections are crucial because they serve as the foundation for building the party's roots. If the basic and metropolitan party organizations collapse, the repercussions will inevitably continue into the 2028 National Assembly elections.



The People Power Party leadership must fundamentally change how it handles internal conflict. As long as there are suspicions that disciplinary action or nomination exclusions are being used for power consolidation, internal divisions will persist. If the party fails to restore even the minimum level of fairness and procedural legitimacy, it may end up being judged not by the courts, but by the voters themselves.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing