[Why&Next] Aftermath of Amended Commercial Act... Emart's Integration of Shinsegae Food 'Halted'
Controversy Over the Stock Exchange Ratio and Minority Shareholder Opposition
PBR at 0.59, 3% Premium... Criticism Over ‘Lack of Real Premium’
FSS Requests Corrections—Scrutiny on Disclosure Adequacy and Investor Protection
The plan to make Shinsegae Food a wholly owned subsidiary of Emart has come to a halt. This pause comes as financial authorities raised concerns over the fairness of the share swap ratio and a lack of sufficient information for investment decisions. Attention is now focused on how the Ministry of Justice's "Guidelines on Directors' Code of Conduct," announced in February following amendments to the Commercial Act that strengthened directors' fiduciary duties, is being applied to actual transactions.
According to industry sources on April 3, the Financial Supervisory Service requested Emart and Shinsegae Food to submit an amended securities registration statement for their comprehensive share swap and transfer filing, which was submitted on March 30. The Financial Supervisory Service explained through a public disclosure that it made this request because the securities registration statement either failed to meet formal requirements, contained false or missing material information, or included unclear statements that could impede rational investment decisions.
Why is Emart Swapping Shares with Shinsegae Food?
Emart has been pursuing a share swap to make Shinsegae Food its 100% subsidiary. The purpose is to resolve the dual listing structure between the two companies and to simplify the decision-making system. The share swap date is scheduled for June 8.
The share swap will proceed by having Shinsegae Food shareholders hand over their shares to Emart in exchange for Emart shares. The exchange ratio is set at 0.5031313 shares of Shinsegae Food for each share of Emart. Emart planned to secure 1,042,112 shares of Shinsegae Food (26.91%), excluding treasury shares and its existing stake, in order to make Shinsegae Food a wholly owned subsidiary.
The two companies stated that the exchange price was calculated based on market prices. Emart was valued at 99,757 won per share, and Shinsegae Food at 50,191 won per share. For minority shareholder protection, Shinsegae Food applied a 3% premium to the arithmetic average price. Typically, the share swap between listed companies is based on market prices, and an external valuation is not mandatory.
Controversy Over the '1 Emart : 2 Shinsegae Food' Share Swap Ratio
However, controversy over the swap ratio has continued since the deal was announced. With Shinsegae Food's price-to-book ratio (PBR) standing at about 0.59 times, there have been claims that the company is undervalued relative to its book value. Previously, the company sold its food service division last year for 120 billion won, about four times its PBR, but the share swap reference price for minority shareholders only reflected about half of the asset value.
There has also been criticism that Emart's use of its existing treasury shares to pay Shinsegae Food shareholders circumvents the intent of the amended Commercial Act, which requires the cancellation of treasury shares.
Additionally, Shinsegae Food offered a share repurchase price of 48,876 won to shareholders who oppose the swap. The gap with the exchange price (50,191 won) is about 2.7%. Compared with the typical premium given to minority shareholders in governance restructuring deals, the actual benefit is limited.
The lack of verification from an external valuation agency is also a point of contention. While not legally required, given that the deal is between a controlling shareholder and a subsidiary, there are calls for further explanation of the price fairness. The companies stated that they ensured fairness through a special committee composed mainly of outside directors, and by seeking advice from external accounting and law firms.
Following the request for corrections, the share swap schedule is also expected to be adjusted. The companies must submit the amended filing within three months. If not submitted, the securities registration statement will be considered withdrawn.
Stricter Review Standards Amid Minority Shareholder Backlash... The Dual Listing Dilemma
This action is closely related to the recent trend of strengthening shareholder protection. Since last year, with successive amendments to the Commercial Act, the Financial Supervisory Service has applied stricter review standards to deals that draw large-scale backlash from minority shareholders.
The "Guidelines on Directors' Code of Conduct," announced by the Ministry of Justice on February 25, clarified the principle that directors must make decisions considering the interests of all shareholders, not just the company. This case is cited as an example of how the guidelines can be applied in practice, as the board judged the fairness of the deal internally, while the regulatory authorities re-examined the basis and adequacy of public disclosure.
Previously, in February, the Financial Supervisory Service also requested revisions to Hyundai GF Holdings' share swap registration statement. Afterwards, the company submitted supplementary materials, including holding a shareholder meeting and expanding information disclosure.
This transaction illustrates the intersection of corporate governance improvement through the resolution of a dual listing structure and the principle of minority shareholder protection. Currently, both Emart and Shinsegae Food are simultaneously listed as parent and subsidiary, which has raised concerns that the subsidiary's value is being doubly reflected in the parent company's share price or, conversely, not fully reflected. Emart has been promoting the full acquisition of its subsidiary to resolve this issue.
From the corporate perspective, this move aims to simplify the governance structure and improve management efficiency. It could also enhance synergies among affiliates and accelerate strategy implementation. In its board opinion, Shinsegae Food stated, "This share swap is unlikely to cause direct harm to minority shareholders and is in the best interest of all shareholders." The company also argued that the exchange ratio was set at a fair and reasonable level in accordance with relevant laws and regulations.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Shinsegae Food said, "We are currently reviewing the details of the correction request from the relevant authorities and plan to carry out an internal review before making an amended public disclosure."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.