34 Cases Dismissed for Lack of Valid Petition Grounds

"Simple Objection to Court Ruling Not Accepted"

First Syrian Refugee Case Also Dismissed

"Filing Deadline Missed"

The Constitutional Court has dismissed all 48 petitions in its second preliminary review since the implementation of the retrial petition system. For the second consecutive week, not a single case passed the preliminary review to be referred to the full bench for deliberation by all justices.


On March 31, the Constitutional Court announced that each designated panel of three justices had decided to dismiss 48 retrial petitions. Since the implementation of the new system on March 12, the court has cumulatively dismissed 74 out of a total of 256 retrial petitions received as of the previous day.

The Constitutional Court building in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

The Constitutional Court building in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

When a case is filed, the designated panel determines whether it meets the legal requirements. If a petition is deemed inadmissible, it is dismissed without a substantive review. So far, not a single case has cleared this preliminary stage.


The grounds for dismissal included 34 cases of insufficient grounds for petition (including duplicates), 11 cases filed past the deadline, 7 other improper filings, and 1 case lacking supplementary requirements.


The very first case filed under the new retrial petition system was also dismissed due to being filed after the statutory deadline and lacking sufficient grounds. This case involved Mr. Mohammed (42), a Syrian national who sought to overturn a deportation ruling after staying in Korea for about 11 years to escape the Syrian civil war, only to be forcibly deported.


According to the Constitutional Court Act, a retrial petition must be filed within 30 days of the final ruling. However, Mr. Mohammed filed his petition more than two months after his verdict was finalized on January 8 of this year.


Mr. Mohammed's legal representative argued that the retrial petition could not be filed before the system was implemented, and thus the delay should be considered justifiable. However, the court did not accept this as a 'justifiable reason' for missing the deadline.


Regarding the 34 cases dismissed for insufficient grounds—the most common reason—the Constitutional Court reiterated its criteria: petitions are inadmissible if they are asserted in vague or abstract terms; if they raise claims that, in substance, merely dispute factual findings or evaluation of evidence, or the application of law, in individual and concrete cases; or if they are simply appeals against the outcome of a trial, unless a clear violation of fundamental rights is demonstrated. The court cannot recognize such petitions as having sufficient grounds.



In particular, in this round of decisions, the court dismissed a retrial petition that challenged the constitutionality of the legal provision applied in the original trial, ruling that this did not constitute valid grounds for a retrial petition.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing