[Invest&law] Barun and Cho Hyunmoon Clash Over Evidence Requests in Contractual Payment Lawsuit View original image

Barun Law LLC and Cho Hyun-moon, former Executive Vice President of Hyosung, engaged in a heated dispute over evidence requests in a lawsuit concerning a contractual payment of approximately 4.3 billion won.


The 17th Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge: Jang Ji-hye) held a hearing for this contractual payment lawsuit on the 27th. On this day, attorney Lee Seung-chul (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 29th class) from LX Law LLC represented Barun, while attorney Song Gak-yeop (31st class) from YK Law LLC appeared for former Executive Vice President Cho.


The court, Barun, and Cho’s side reviewed requests for orders to submit documents and for fact inquiries. The purpose was to determine whether Barun properly fulfilled its duties as entrusted during the execution of the will of the late Cho Suck-rae, Honorary Chairman of Hyosung Group. Barun asserts that it fully performed its role. Cho’s side counters that Barun did not carry out its work properly but still claimed a success fee. Honorary Chairman Cho passed away in March 2024.


On this day, Barun stated, "The petition filed by former Executive Vice President Cho with the Seoul Bar Association was dismissed." Cho’s side responded, "We immediately appealed to the Korean Bar Association." They continued, "The Seoul Bar Association failed to properly examine the grounds for the disciplinary request and did not give the complainant a fair opportunity to express opinions. We expect the Korean Bar Association to make a fair judgment both procedurally and substantively."


The court continued the hearing to further discuss the evidence requests. The next hearing is scheduled for May 29. Barun had worked with Cho for a long period, but their relationship deteriorated due to disputes over fees and other issues. In September 2024, Cho engaged YK for legal counsel and representation. In October of the same year, Barun filed the contractual payment lawsuit against Cho.


During the hearing on December 5, 2025, the conflict between the two sides was exposed in court. Barun argued, "Former Executive Vice President Cho broke the trust in the attorney-client relationship. The time charge records show in detail, by date, who performed which work. Cho’s side is making unreasonable claims by questioning the credibility of the records." Cho’s side countered, "To receive a success fee, Barun must have performed work matching the essence of the engagement contract. Barun only provided work at the level of supplying forms. The establishment of the public interest foundation was handled by another law firm."



Lee Sang-woo, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing