Samsung Labor Talks at an Impasse... Pros and Cons of Linking 10% of Operating Profit to Incentives
The Dilemma Facing the Samsung Electronics Union
Union Demands for “Expanding the Incentive Pool” Grow Stronger
Four Times the Size of SK Hynix, but Concerns Over Declining Incentives
The intensive wage negotiations between management and the labor union at Samsung Electronics, which began on the 26th, have once again broken down. As the semiconductor boom continues, both sides remain at loggerheads over the "institutionalization of performance-based bonuses," including linking bonuses to operating profit and abolishing the bonus cap. However, some in the industry are concerned that if operating profit is mechanically linked to bonuses as demanded by the union, it could paradoxically result in reduced compensation for employees.
According to the industry on March 31, Samsung Electronics' management and labor union are now awaiting the decision of the Regional Labor Relations Commission following the collapse of intensive wage negotiations. Choi Seungho, the head of the Samsung Electronics branch of the Super Enterprise Union, who is pushing for a general strike in May, stated on the union's website on the 27th, "We plan to file a complaint with the commission, and we will proceed with negotiations based on its outcome." He added, "We have consistently demanded the institutionalization of the Over-Performance Incentive (OPI) scheme, but the company has rejected it."
The crux of the conflict lies in how far to open up the resources for performance-based bonuses. The union is demanding the abolition of the bonus cap and the institutionalization of a scheme that automatically allocates a fixed percentage (10%) of operating profit to bonuses. In contrast, the company maintains that while bonuses should be linked to performance, a certain degree of discretion is necessary to address differences between business divisions and fluctuations in market conditions.
Members of the Samsung Electronics labor union are holding a cultural event on the afternoon of May 24, 2024, in front of the Samsung Electronics headquarters in Gangnam-gu, Seoul, urging for negotiations with the labor union. Photo by Yonhap News.
View original imageThe company explains that if the union's proposal to set aside a fixed "10% of operating profit" for bonuses is implemented, the differences in profitability across business divisions will be directly reflected in compensation disparities. In particular, the System LSI and Foundry divisions—which are less profitable compared to the Memory division—would see a sharp decline in their bonus payout rates, exacerbating internal imbalances. In fact, if the union's proposal were applied as is, the bonus payout rate for the System LSI and Foundry divisions, which was 47% last year, would reportedly plummet to 11%.
There are also concerns that fixing the operating profit linkage ratio could put Samsung Electronics at a disadvantage compared to its competitors. Due to differences in headcount, even with the same profit, the per-person bonus could be lower, potentially undermining the compensation competitiveness of employees in high-performing divisions. According to this year's disclosures, Samsung Electronics had 128,881 employees last year, while its competitor SK hynix had 34,549—nearly a fourfold difference. An industry source explained, "If the '10% of operating profit' allocation is mechanically applied, the bonus payout rate for the Memory division would fall to less than half that of SK hynix due to the significant difference in headcount." He added, "This is why management promised special incentives during the intensive bargaining."
Accordingly, the company proposed a special incentive plan that maintains a certain cap but commits to injecting additional resources based on business performance to guarantee compensation exceeding that of competitors. Related organizations would receive 70% of the standard payout rate, while the System LSI and Foundry (semiconductor contract manufacturing) divisions would see their OPI payout increase from the current 50% up to a maximum of 75%. The offer also included a 6.2% wage increase (comprised of a 4.1% base raise and a 2.1% performance-based raise), the introduction of a housing loan program providing up to 500 million won for employees without homes, increased childbirth and family event allowances, as well as higher salary caps by career level, all aimed at expanding employee benefits.
However, the union has insisted that only the institutionalization of the OPI scheme is acceptable, leading to a breakdown in negotiations. The union has announced plans for a rally on April 23 and is preparing for a general strike in May.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An industry source commented, "The union’s demands are focused solely on the interests of the Device Solutions (DS) division, particularly those in the Memory division. The comprehensive welfare benefits proposed by management—such as a 6.2% wage increase, the introduction of a housing support program offering up to 500 million won, and increases to salary caps by rank—are being completely overshadowed and ignored."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.