Fewer Co-ownership Disputes,
Greater Financial Burden
Direct Impact on
Corporate Succession Structures

[Invest&Law] Reserved Share Now to Be Paid in Monetary Value Instead of Shares View original image

With the amendment of the Civil Act’s statutory reserved share provisions, the principle for returning the reserved share has shifted to payment in monetary value, prompting analysis that inheritance planning and dispute responses will need to be reconsidered. As the contribution system has also been partially revised and the scope of those losing inheritance rights has expanded, significant changes are expected throughout inheritance practices.


◆Switch from 'share' to 'monetary value' = The amended Civil Act stipulates that, in cases where the reserved share is insufficient, the claimant may now demand payment of the monetary value, rather than the return of the property itself as before. The regulation also mandates interest accrual from the date the claim for monetary payment is made, thereby changing the burden structure for the party obligated to return the share.


Previously, returns were often made in the form of real estate or stock shares, leading to cases where co-ownership relationships were formed or partition sales by auction occurred. With the adoption of the monetary payment method, such issues are expected to decrease; however, the party obligated to return the share will now bear the direct burden of raising cash.


In practice, it is believed that this change will particularly affect corporate succession structures. Previously, it was possible to design succession plans that minimized the impact on management rights by combining holdings in holding and subsidiary companies, as well as inter vivos gifts and bequests. However, with the recognition of the reserved share now resulting in inevitable monetary payments, the response strategy may need to change.


At the Inheritance Trust Research Association seminar held on March 19 at the Barun Law LLC office in Daechi-dong, Seoul, Woonggyu Cho (41st Judicial Research and Training Institute class), attorney at Barun Law LLC, explained, "Previously, it was possible to address the reserved share issue through share structuring, but with the amendment, the structure ultimately leads to a financial burden. In corporate succession cases, how to secure the resources for repayment could become a major issue."


◆Proof of 'filial piety' likely to intensify = Regulations related to the contribution system are also cited as major variables in practice. The amended law stipulates that, in cases of gifts or bequests given as compensation for providing special care to the decedent or contributing to the preservation or increase of assets, such gifts or bequests are not regarded as special benefits within the corresponding scope (Article 1008, Civil Act proviso). Accordingly, these portions are excluded from the calculation of the reserved share.


As a result, in lawsuits demanding the return of the reserved share, the existence and extent of contributions, beyond simple calculation of statutory inheritance shares, are expected to become key issues for verification. How the courts evaluate contributions in inheritance property division cases and in reserved share cases will also be a significant practical variable.


A notary public attorney stated, "When notarizing a will, I usually advise clients to leave three specifics: who received what property during the decedent's lifetime, who contributed to support or asset creation, and what actions were taken. Organizing these details is necessary."


◆Expanded role for family courts = The system for loss of inheritance rights has also seen its scope expanded. The amended law allows the family court to declare loss of inheritance rights for any heir—including lineal ascendants, lineal descendants, and spouses—if they seriously violate their duty of support, commit a serious crime, or subject the decedent to grossly unfair treatment. Because the family court can conduct fact-finding ex officio, the structure is interpreted as allowing consideration of the entire family relationship.


If loss of inheritance rights is recognized, the affected heir loses not only their status as an heir but is also disqualified from the reserved share, with this effect retroactive to the commencement of inheritance. Whether inheritance rights are lost is determined by comprehensively considering the circumstances and degree of the reason, as well as the relationship between the heir and the decedent.


However, as requirements such as "serious violation of the duty of support" and "grossly unfair treatment" are defined only in abstract terms, practical confusion is expected for the time being. Attorney Cho commented, "The specific recognition criteria will likely be established through future case law."


Additionally, the structure for substitute inheritance has been partially adjusted. If an heir is disqualified or has been declared to have lost inheritance rights, their spouse is now ineligible for substitute inheritance. While substitute inheritance due to death remains unchanged, spouses who are disqualified or have lost inheritance rights are excluded, leaving only lineal descendants eligible for substitute inheritance.


The provisions on loss of inheritance rights and contribution system will retroactively apply to inheritances commenced after April 25, 2024. However, the monetary payment rule for returning the reserved share applies only to inheritance cases commencing on or after March 17, when the amended law came into effect.



Legal Times Reporter Hanju Cho


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing