[Financial Microscope] Card Companies on Edge Over Possible 'Maximum Sanctions' Against Lotte Card
Card Industry: "We Can't Ignore the Neighbor's 'Fixing the Barn'"
Losing Trust with Authorities Is as Serious as Losing Consumer Trust
Damage Is Significant, but Some Say It's a Catalyst for Budget and Organizational Reform
Lotte Card, which caused a personal information leak affecting 2.97 million customers, is facing the risk of the most severe disciplinary actions from financial authorities, including business suspension and a recommendation to dismiss its Chief Executive Officer (CEO). This has put the entire credit card industry on edge. As the sector as a whole is struggling to secure profitability, there is a growing sense of crisis that a dedicated credit card company may find it difficult to recover if it receives heavy disciplinary action from regulators. The prevailing sentiment is that "an accident must absolutely be avoided."
Lotte Card Likely to Face Severe Penalties for Institution and CEO
Financial Supervisory Service Governor Chan Jin Lee is speaking at the monthly press briefing held on the 26th of last month. Financial Supervisory Service
View original imageAccording to the financial industry on April 1, the Financial Supervisory Service plans to bring the disciplinary case concerning Lotte Card’s cyber breach to its Sanctions Review Committee soon. Under Article 59 of the Enforcement Rule of the Regulations on Inspections and Sanctions of Financial Institutions, the Financial Supervisory Service must notify the institution at least 10 days prior to the committee meeting. Industry sources report that the Financial Supervisory Service issued a preliminary notice to Lotte Card about the sanctions proposal last week.
According to the financial sector, Lotte Card violated the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act, the Credit Information Use and Protection Act, and the Personal Information Protection Act. Regulatory sanctions are expected to focus primarily on the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act and the Credit Information Use and Protection Act. Under the Specialized Credit Finance Business Act, the most severe sanction is a six-month business suspension. The Credit Information Use and Protection Act allows for a maximum fine of 5 billion won. In addition, on March 11, Lotte Card was fined 9.62 billion won in penalties and 4.8 million won in administrative fines by the Personal Information Protection Commission for violating the Personal Information Protection Act.
Furthermore, there is a significant possibility that former executives, including former CEO Cho Jwajin, who resigned in December last year, could also face sanctions. Even former executives can be subject to dismissal recommendations or reprimands from authorities if unlawful actions are confirmed. A Financial Supervisory Service official stated, “The core of the sanctions is which regulations Lotte Card violated, so it is difficult to confirm specific facts at this stage.”
Industry: "The Impact Is Greater Than 10 Years Ago"
The regulatory action against Lotte Card is expected to have a significant impact on the entire industry. Industry consensus is that, although sanctions were anticipated, both the severity and timing are particularly problematic. Since last September, right after former CEO Cho issued a public apology and following an on-site inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service, the industry had anticipated a scenario involving a six-month business suspension and a 5 billion won fine. However, the scale of the penalty imposed by the Personal Information Protection Commission has exceeded expectations.
With the entire sector struggling to recover profitability, the fact that a mid-tier company is facing severe disciplinary action has heightened tensions. In the past, there have been two instances of business suspensions for credit card companies: in 2002 and 2014. In 2002, Samsung Card and LG Card (now Shinhan Card) were each suspended for two months, and Korea Exchange Bank Card (now Hana Card) for one and a half months, due to illegal activities such as issuing cards through unqualified agents and recruiting members on the street. In 2014, Lotte Card, KB Kookmin Card, and NH Nonghyup Card were suspended for three months after leaking and selling the credit information of 104 million customers to Korea Credit Bureau (KCB). An industry official stated, “In the past, the industry was strong enough that, even with regulatory sanctions, companies could restore profitability through capital injections and other means. Now, with weak profitability, it is much harder for credit card companies to recover after heavy disciplinary action from regulators.”
Taeyoung Chung, Vice Chairman of Hyundai Card, also commented on the Lotte Card cyber incident at a press briefing last September, stating, “This is not someone else’s problem,” and adding, “It’s not something that can be resolved just with a budget. Sometimes you need to shake up the organization and take a fresh look.”
Trust in Authorities as Well as Consumer Confidence at Stake
Sehoon Lee, Senior Deputy Governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, is speaking at the Financial Supervisory Service headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul. Photo by Chaeseok Moon
View original imageThe industry is also concerned that if severe disciplinary action against Lotte Card becomes a reality, it could further erode regulatory trust in the credit card sector. The financial authorities’ stance of imposing strict penalties for IT incidents is another negative factor. On March 20, Sehun Lee, Senior Deputy Governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, warned at a press conference following the first Consumer Risk Response Council meeting that if a financial company fails to sufficiently test new IT systems, they could face fines and penalties under the Electronic Financial Transactions Act and the Credit Information Use and Protection Act. He emphasized there would be “no leniency.” Lee further stressed, “If companies neglect basic management duties such as IT (security) investments and incidents occur, we will impose definite financial penalties.”
A credit card industry official said, “Losing the trust of the authorities is just as serious as losing consumer trust. Once trust is lost, even dramatic measures such as the CEO stepping down or organizational restructuring may not be enough for recovery.”
Budget and Organizational Reform Warnings Seen as Positive
Some in the industry believe that the severe disciplinary action against Lotte Card could serve as a catalyst to enhance consumer protection frameworks across the sector. On March 18, Lotte Card established the “Trust Management Consumer Committee,” while Shinhan Card set up a Consumer Protection Committee within its board. Woori Card is preparing to establish a consumer protection unit within its board, and KB Kookmin Card has elevated its Consumer Protection Division to a Consumer Protection Group. Industry leader Samsung Card has also strengthened its expert panel within the Consumer Protection Committee.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An industry official commented, “If your neighbor loses a cow and fixes his barn, you can’t afford to neglect your own barn. If severe disciplinary action becomes a reality, paradoxically, it could accelerate the implementation of regulatory policies and strengthen consumer protection systems across the sector.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.