"Look at the Iran War... Trump's 'Golden Dome' Needs Reassessment" - CATO Institute View original image

U.S. President Donald Trump’s space-based next-generation missile defense system, the “Golden Dome,” announced in May last year, is facing calls for reconsideration. Despite its astronomical costs, recent events in the Iran war demonstrate that missile defense systems can still fail.


Critics argue that the system’s potential failure should be weighed against factors such as Iran’s ability to overwhelm Israel’s Iron Dome and air and missile defense (AMD) system with large barrages of missiles and drones, as well as the projected costs of building the Golden Dome, which could range from $844 billion to $1.1 trillion.


The U.S. libertarian think tank, the CATO Institute, raised these concerns in an article titled “Additional Concerns Regarding President Trump’s ‘Golden Dome’” published on March 27 (local time).


The U.S. Department of Defense increased the budget for the Golden Dome by $10 billion this March, bringing it to $185 billion (approximately 275 trillion won). However, analyses suggest the total cost could reach as high as $1.1 trillion.


The Golden Dome aims to establish a multi-layered defense network that extends beyond traditional ground-based interceptor systems to include space, high-altitude, and low-altitude coverage. Its core relies on space-based interceptor satellites and surveillance and tracking satellite networks. However, these technologies have never been deployed in actual combat, making their costs and technical feasibility the most significant uncertainties.


The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that building a space-based interceptor satellite system alone could require between $161 billion and $542 billion. Bloomberg analyzed that, under a worst-case scenario in which China, Russia, and North Korea simultaneously launch large-scale aerial attacks, the total cost to build the Golden Dome could reach about $1.1 trillion. This figure is more than five times higher than the cost estimate provided by the Department of Defense.


The following is a summary of the key points.


The Iran war revealed both the strengths and limitations of the forces involved. Above all, Iran was able to put significant pressure on, and at times even breach, Israel’s much-vaunted missile defense network. This underscores just how difficult it is to build a reliable shield against modern threats. The United States must take this seriously. The Golden Dome, as proposed by the Trump administration, is modeled after Israel’s Iron Dome and AMD systems. However, the very systems serving as its model have now exposed clear vulnerabilities. If Israel’s defense network can be tested in such a way, the lesson for the United States is clear: similar attempts risk wasting enormous amounts of time, money, and resources on promises that may ultimately go unfulfilled.


During this war, Iran overwhelmed Israel’s AMD system with massive barrages of missiles. This is a definitive method to neutralize missile defense systems. By launching multiple missiles at once, or equipping a single missile with multiple warheads or bombs, attackers can penetrate defense networks. Most recently, Iran combined ballistic missiles with cluster munitions to defeat Israel’s AMD. Essentially, Iran is launching attacks at a scale that defense networks cannot withstand.


It is not difficult to imagine China and Russia being able to overwhelm the U.S. Golden Dome system as well. In particular, the Golden Dome’s interceptor missiles would have to defend an area 400 times larger than Israel’s. Russia and China possess greater and more advanced missile capabilities than Iran, including intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), which are extremely difficult to intercept.


Comparing the costs of homeland missile defense systems with those of offensive missiles also raises further doubts about the feasibility of the Golden Dome. Even in the Iran war, the cost of Tehran’s offensive was lower than the cost of missile defense munitions used by Israel and the United States. For example, a single THAAD interceptor missile is estimated to cost about $12.7 million, whereas an Iranian ballistic missile costs between $1 million and $2 million.


If a country with limited economic power like Iran can pose such a threat to Israel’s AMD system, then nations with far greater resources could certainly penetrate the Golden Dome, whose cost to U.S. taxpayers is estimated at $844 billion to $1.1 trillion.


When considering defense investments, the Department of Defense and policymakers should determine whether a given weapon or system truly serves U.S. national interests and aligns with U.S. defense strategy. The Golden Dome fails to meet this standard. The core issue is opportunity cost: why should the United States spend hundreds of billions, or even trillions, of dollars on a missile defense system with a high probability of failure? The federal government could use this money far more effectively elsewhere, rather than wasting it on a defense system offering little strategic benefit to the U.S.



With more than $30 billion already spent on the Iran war, and the Department of Defense’s 2027 fiscal year budget expected to reach $1.5 trillion, pouring additional taxpayer money into yet another inefficient defense project is the last thing Americans need.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing