Endless Debate Over Real Estate Policy
A Robust System Matters More Than Political Victory

[Inside Chodong] The Implications of "Lee Jae-myung Gets Things Done" View original image

The pledge to suspend the heavy capital gains tax on owners of multiple homes was a campaign promise made by Yoon Suk-yeol during the 2022 presidential election. Among his real estate pledges, it was the first to be implemented, with the intention of reversing the excessive taxes imposed during the Moon Jae-in administration. At the time, soaring housing prices in Seoul led to severe housing instability, putting the then-ruling Democratic Party of Korea on the defensive.


Lee Jae-myung, who ran as the Democratic Party’s presidential candidate in the same election, also pledged a conditional suspension of the heavy capital gains tax at the time. That is why it felt somewhat unusual earlier this year when President Lee was the first to clearly state, “There will be no suspension of the heavy tax,” at a time when public officials were uncertain about the policy direction.


Even before his inauguration, Yoon Suk-yeol’s campaign team took steps to fulfill this pledge. Choi Sang-mok, then secretary of the first economic subcommittee of the Presidential Transition Committee, announced, “We have decided to work toward the temporary exclusion of the heavy capital gains tax rate on owners of multiple homes for one year starting in April.” While this was framed as an effort, it was, in effect, a veiled threat to the outgoing administration. Less than a month after the election, they requested an amendment to the Enforcement Decree of the Income Tax Act.


Although the request was formally polite, the incoming administration, buoyed by its victory, treated the outgoing government as obsolete. The Moon administration refused. The following month, on May 10, the Yoon administration took office and made the amendment. From then on, the decree was revised annually for four years. This is the background behind the policy being reinstated on May 10.


President Lee frequently posts messages about real estate policy on social networking services (SNS), often repeating phrases like “Lee Jae-myung gets things done” and “The government of popular sovereignty gets things done.” His confidence stems from his administrative experience as a local government chief, his meticulous work style, and his bold personality. This stands in stark contrast to former presidents who resigned due to legal violations. It also serves as fuel to rally his supporters and gain momentum for policy implementation.


Regardless of how one interprets the intent of the policy, there is a sense of unease about the president taking such a direct role in these affairs. While this approach certainly ensures strong initiative, it also turns the process into a high-level political act. The phrase “Lee Jae-myung gets things done” implies that a future president could also use political support to overturn policy at will. Wasn’t that exactly what happened just four years ago?


Under the Yoon administration, with the opposition holding a majority in the National Assembly, the government was unable to amend the law as intended and instead revised the enforcement decree each year. It is a familiar scene. When setting the officially assessed prices of homes and land, which serve as the tax base, the administration would arbitrarily determine the market reflection rate and the fair market value ratio without clear standards, depending on the government in power. As a result, real estate policy became a battleground for political power struggles. The flexible application of the system according to political support is not something to be welcomed. The lack of a solid framework for the system leads to endless, wasteful debates, and the constant uncertainty attracts speculative capital seeking one-off gains.



There have been attempts to strengthen the system. Plans were announced to gradually raise the market reflection rate, and constitutional complaints were filed claiming that the officially assessed prices and fair market value ratios violated the principle of taxation by law. Both efforts ultimately came to nothing. In my view, the object of the phrase “Lee Jae-myung gets things done” should not simply be about collecting more taxes or lowering housing prices, but about establishing a robust system that is not swayed by changes in administration or political turbulence.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing