Song Bohyun / Honam Bureau Reporter

[Reporter’s Notebook] "Is There Anyone Who Would Like to Ask a Question?"... A Defining Moment Left by the Policy Jury System View original image

"Is there anyone who would like to ask a question?"


On the afternoon of March 29 in Gwangju, the moderator repeated this question during the policy jury panel discussion for the Democratic Party's unified special mayoral candidate for Jeonnam and Gwangju. Few jury members were willing to raise their hands. The brief silence that followed seemed to symbolize the inherent limitations of this policy jury system.


The policy jury system was introduced as a citizen-participatory verification mechanism in the primary process to select the first unified special mayoral candidate representing approximately 3.2 million residents of Jeonnam and Gwangju after their unification. The intention was to allow citizens to directly evaluate the candidates' policy capabilities, political philosophy, and vision for the future. Expectations were high, as it was seen as an attempt to open the debate stage of the party's primary to the public.


In practice, during the Gwangju debate, citizens posed direct questions about policy directions such as the use of 20 trillion won in fiscal incentives after unification, environmental policies, the outflow of local talent to the Seoul metropolitan area, strategies for fostering advanced industries, and plans to expand youth cultural and leisure infrastructure. It was clear that the goal was to assess candidates' policy choices from the citizens' perspective.


However, the event also revealed operational limitations that made it difficult to see the entire discussion as an effective policy review. There were instances of awkward transitions in the order and timing of questions, and at times, no questions were raised when it was a jury member's turn. As the moderator repeatedly prompted the audience, the flow of the debate was frequently interrupted.


The policy jury system was implemented as an alternative to the citizen candidate jury system initially considered by the party's central nomination management committee. The jury panel was not granted voting rights. Instead, citizens were limited to the role of questioners rather than decision-makers. This structural limitation was the reason why concerns about the system's effectiveness were raised from the design stage.


Additionally, it is worth noting that the regional composition of the jury and the instant Q&A debate format were only established about two weeks before the primary. Constructing a deliberative structure that encourages citizen participation is difficult with such a short preparation period. The quality of questions and depth of the debate inevitably reflect the system’s design and the amount of preparation time.


Still, it would be unfair to dismiss this attempt as a meaningless experiment. During the actual debate, there were direct questions concerning the direction of fiscal incentive usage after unification, priorities for industrial strategy, youth policy, and cultural infrastructure. Citizens also had opportunities to gauge the direction of policy choices.



The policy jury system, first introduced in the primary to select the inaugural unified special mayoral candidate, revealed both its potential and its limitations. While the direction of citizen participation became clearer, the process also highlighted the need for a more detailed operational design and a reexamination of the authority structure to ensure that participation leads to meaningful policy review. What became evident when the questions stopped was not so much the limitation of citizen participation, but rather the current state of a system that remains incomplete.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing