Restriction on Combined Rental Car and Designated Driver Services Upheld as Constitutional

Constitutional Court: “Public Interest Takes Priority... No Infringement on Freedom of Occupation”

The Constitutional Court has ruled that the current law restricting vehicle-sharing services that combine rental cars and designated driver services does not violate the Constitution.


According to Yonhap News on March 29, the Constitutional Court dismissed the constitutional complaint against Article 34, Paragraph 2, Subparagraph 2 of the Passenger Transport Service Act by a vote of 8 to 1, ruling that the law is constitutional.


This provision limits situations in which a rental car user can request a designated driver to only cases of “intoxication” or where “direct driving is impossible due to physical injury or similar circumstances.” Commonly known as the “Tada Ban Law,” this regulation was amended in 2020 amid conflicts between platform mobility services and the taxi industry.


The companies that filed the constitutional complaint had been operating ride-hailing services combining rental cars with designated drivers through a smartphone app. In this structure, a driver would operate a rental car, and upon accepting a ride request, the existing rental contract would be terminated and a new contract would be signed between the passenger and the rental car company, after which the service would be provided in the form of a designated driver. In effect, this is very similar to a taxi service.


Taxis waiting to pick up passengers. The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Photo by Yonhap News.

Taxis waiting to pick up passengers. The photo is not directly related to the content of the article. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

The complainants argued that the provision violates the principle of legal clarity and infringes on their freedom of occupational choice. However, the Constitutional Court found that “a person of sound common sense and ordinary legal sensibility can fully anticipate the meaning of ‘intoxication’ and ‘physical injury,’” and thus did not view it as a violation of the clarity principle.


The court also pointed out that “if businesses essentially duplicate taxi transportation services while circumventing the strict regulations applied to the taxi industry, it would be difficult to ensure the safety of passenger transport services, as well as to secure fair competition and regulatory equity with existing operators.”


Regarding the claim that the regulation effectively restricts platform-based transport services and violates the principle of proportionality, the Constitutional Court stated, “Given the need to maintain the public nature of passenger transport services and market order, it is difficult to consider the regulation to be unjust.” The court added, “The passenger transport service business has a significant impact on the daily lives and safety of the public and includes important public interest elements,” and “it is difficult to see the restriction on occupational freedom as excessive.”



However, Justice Kim Bokhyeong dissented, stating, “The law fundamentally blocks the entry of new transportation businesses that combine short-term vehicle rentals and designated driver services,” and “from the perspective of hindering the achievement of the public goal of technological innovation, the restriction on fundamental rights is by no means minor.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing