"Claimed to Have Accidentally Touched the Gear Lever"

Court: "Wearing a Thick Padded Jacket Makes It Plausible"

A man in his 50s who was put on trial for driving under the influence for a distance of 2 meters was acquitted after the court recognized that the driving occurred by mistake.


According to Yonhap News on March 29, the Cheongju District Court Criminal Division 3 (Presiding Judge Ji Yunseob) recently found defendant A, who had been charged without detention for violating the Road Traffic Act, not guilty.

Exterior view of Cheongju District Court

Exterior view of Cheongju District Court

View original image

On December 23, 2024, at approximately 1:23 a.m., A was accused of driving his own passenger car for about 2 meters under the influence of alcohol on a road in Yongam-dong, Sangdang-gu, Cheongju, North Chungcheong Province. At the time, his blood alcohol concentration was 0.097%, which is above the license cancellation threshold.


During the trial, A argued that the car moved by accident. He stated, "I called for a substitute driver and sat in the driver's seat to start the engine so I could turn on the heater. Then, as I leaned over to the passenger side storage compartment to get the fare for the substitute driver, my foot slipped off the brake and the gear shifted into drive during this process."


The court found A's explanation that the car moved by mistake to be credible.


The court said, "Considering the distance and speed that the vehicle moved, it does not appear that the defendant operated the vehicle by intentionally pressing the accelerator. Moreover, since A was wearing a thick padded jacket at the time, there is a sufficient possibility that he accidentally touched the gear lever while leaning over inside the car to retrieve something." The court continued, "If the defendant had intended to drive under the influence, he would not have called a substitute driver, and since his acquaintance B, who was living with him at the time, was outside the vehicle, there was no reason to leave B behind. Taking all of this into account, the evidence presented by the prosecution is insufficient to recognize a willful act of driving by the defendant," explaining the reason for the not-guilty verdict. The prosecution has appealed the ruling.



Meanwhile, in the past, there was a similar case in which a drunk driver was acquitted after their car, with the driver's door open, suddenly moved 3 meters and hit a utility pole. In that case, the court ruled not guilty, reasoning that it was difficult to regard the movement of the vehicle as "driving" under the Road Traffic Act. Referring to a Supreme Court precedent, the court explained, "Driving under the Road Traffic Act refers only to intentional driving behavior, and does not apply to cases where a car moves without the will or involvement of the person inside the vehicle."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing