“Continued Interaction Recognized During Second Marriage, Including Helping Raise Grandchildren”

Even if a mediation record includes a provision stating that the marital relationship had broken down, the period of marriage cannot be excluded from calculating the military pension division if the marital relationship is substantively recognized, according to a recent court ruling.

Seoul Administrative Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Seoul Administrative Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on March 29, the Administrative Division 3 of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Choi Sujin) ruled against the plaintiff, referred to as A, in a lawsuit filed against the head of the Armed Forces Financial Management Corps seeking to cancel the decision not to recalculate the pension division ratio, on January 23.


From November 1972 to April 2007, A served as a member of the military. A married B in 1977, divorced by mutual agreement in June 2000, remarried B in April 2007, and divorced again in September 2020. The mediation record for the second divorce included a provision stating “the military pension shall be divided and paid according to the Military Pension Act after the divorce,” as well as a statement acknowledging “the breakdown of the marital relationship since 2000.”


In October 2020, B applied to the Armed Forces Financial Management Corps for a divided military pension in accordance with the Military Pension Act. In November 2020, the Corps sent a notice to A stating that the combined duration of the first and second marriages, totaling 21 years and 3 months, would be recognized as the period of marriage for the calculation of the divided pension.


In September 2024, A requested the Corps to recalculate the pension division ratio, arguing that there was no substantive marital relationship during the second marriage. However, on September 30 of the same year, the Corps notified A that recalculation was not possible, leading A to file a lawsuit in response.


A asserted, “The second marriage existed only on paper, due to our daughter’s marriage and other reasons, and we did not cohabit, so there was no substantive marital relationship.” A further argued that, since the mediation record at the time of divorce included a provision acknowledging the breakdown of the marriage since 2000, the period of the second marriage should be excluded from the calculation of the divided pension.


However, the court did not accept these arguments. The court explained that, for a case to be regarded as a “separately determined pension division” under the Military Pension Act, there must be an explicit agreement between the parties to determine a different pension division ratio, or the court must have made a different ruling. The court found that the evidence submitted by A was insufficient to recognize that there was no substantive marital relationship during the period of the second marriage.



The court further noted that, even if there is a related provision in the mediation record, unless there is a specific provision concerning the actual marital period or the pension division ratio, it cannot be considered as such. Additionally, the fact that A and B continued to interact, such as helping to raise their grandchildren during the second marriage, was also taken as grounds for recognizing a substantive marital relationship.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing