Court: "Extremely Severe Physical Force Caused Significant Harm"

A man in his 70s who assaulted his neighbor and attempted to murder him over a misunderstanding about noise between floors has been sentenced to a heavy prison term again on appeal.


On March 27, the Daejeon High Court’s Criminal Division 1-2, presided over by Chief Judge Lee Sunmi, dismissed the appeal of Mr. A (age 72), who was indicted on charges of attempted murder, and upheld the original sentence of 17 years in prison. The order for five years of probation following the completion of the prison term was also maintained.


Court image. The Asia Business Daily DB

Court image. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

Mr. A was brought to trial on charges of attempting to kill his neighbor, Mr. B (age 67), by striking him dozens of times on the head and other parts of his body at an apartment complex in Daejeon on May 9 last year.


According to the investigation, Mr. A had long harbored resentment, mistakenly believing that Mr. B was causing noise between floors. He assaulted Mr. B in a fit of rage after encountering him by chance.


At the time, another resident passing by intervened, saving Mr. B’s life. However, Mr. B suffered serious injuries, remaining unconscious for about three weeks before regaining consciousness.


The court of first instance sentenced Mr. A to 17 years in prison. The first trial judge stated, “The defendant arbitrarily believed that the victim was causing noise between floors and beat the victim dozens of times upon encountering him by chance. If emergency measures had been delayed, the worst possible outcome could have occurred. Therefore, a severe punishment corresponding to the gravity of the crime is unavoidable.”



Mr. A argued that he had no intent to kill and was in a diminished mental state, but the appeals court did not accept this claim. The second trial judge stated, “The defendant exerted extremely serious physical force on the victim, resulting in significant harm. Based on witness testimony and other evidence, intent to kill is recognized. The evidence does not support the defendant’s claim of mental incapacity. Given the victim's critical condition and the family's plea for severe punishment, there is no basis to reduce the sentence in favor of the defendant.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing