[Economy Pulse] Shin Hyun Song's Perspective and the Reality of the Global Digital Finance Ecosystem View original image

On March 22, President Lee Jae-myung nominated Hyun Song Shin, head of the Monetary and Economic Department at the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), as the next governor of the Bank of Korea. Expectations are high, given that a globally renowned scholar in international finance and macroeconomics will lead the central bank at a time of heightened uncertainty at home and abroad. Shin is also well known for having taken a leading role in discussions on central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) and tokenization during his tenure at the BIS. By contrast, he has consistently maintained a critical stance toward stablecoins.


In reports he authored at the BIS, Shin clearly points to the limitations of today's financial system, where the transmission of messages and the transfer of assets are fragmented. For example, when you buy something with a credit card, the payment may appear to be completed instantly, but the actual funds do not reach the merchant until several days later, after passing through multiple intermediaries, including the card company and banks. The issue President Lee recently raised - "I sold stocks today, so why does the money arrive two days later?" - also stems from the inherent limitations of the current financial system.


Stablecoins, by contrast, use blockchain technology to transfer money anywhere in the world over the internet in real time and at low cost, much like sending an email. Shin, however, believes stablecoins could undermine the singleness of money because they may not maintain a fully one-to-one exchange value, depending on who issues them. As an alternative, he proposes the idea of a "unified ledger" that brings central bank money, bank deposits, and assets such as government bonds onto a single programmable platform.


However, the practicality of this solution needs to be carefully examined. A vast unified ledger shared by everyone may seem seamless in theory, but in reality it would intensify the problem of a single point of failure. Efficiency is not the only thing that matters in financial infrastructure. It is equally important to prevent a failure from spreading across the entire system when shocks occur, such as hacking, war, terrorism, software defects, or operational errors. Putting everything on a single ledger may be convenient in normal times, but an unexpected geopolitical conflict or a large-scale system failure could paralyze the global financial network.


Who would have control is also a major issue. Who would design, operate, and ultimately control an integrated infrastructure combining central bank money, bank deposits, and financial assets? This is not merely a technical question; it concerns authority and accountability, and ultimately monetary sovereignty. Project Agorá, for example, is a major experiment involving seven central banks, including the Bank of Korea, and 43 financial institutions. Yet one of its key tasks is to examine legal and regulatory issues across multiple jurisdictions, settlement finality, and compliance. In other words, governance needs to be settled before technology. Moreover, it is questionable whether any single entity could persuade the central banks or governments of individual countries to reach agreement on how control over critical financial infrastructure should be allocated.


The pace of innovation in the public and private sectors also differs dramatically. Project Agorá began in April 2024 and has announced plans to publish a report in the first half of 2026. The private sector, meanwhile, is already far ahead. As of March 27, the global circulating supply of stablecoins stood at approximately $315.3 billion. Around $164 billion (52.6%) was on the Ethereum network alone, while Tron accounted for approximately $86 billion (27.3%) and Solana approximately $15.2 billion (4.8%). Networks are also interconnected through bridge technologies such as Circle's CCTP (Cross-Chain Transfer Protocol). While the public sector experiments with next-generation infrastructure, the private sector is already building a vast global financial ecosystem by launching services first, connecting different networks, and addressing problems by supplementing rules after the fact.


The most decisive factor is the United States' direction. In January 2025, the Trump Administration issued an executive order setting out a direction to halt federal efforts to develop a CBDC. In July of the same year, it established the first federal regulatory framework for stablecoins through the GENIUS Act. The law requires issuers to hold 100% reserves in highly liquid assets such as dollars or short-term Treasury securities and to disclose the composition of their reserve assets every month. The White House has publicly stated that dollar-based stablecoins will increase demand for U.S. Treasury securities and strengthen the dollar's status as the world's reserve currency.


Taking all these circumstances into account, the practical solution is clear. Rather than having central banks directly build massive integrated infrastructure that resolves every issue involving security, scalability, privacy, interoperability, and governance, it is far more feasible to build trust that stablecoins can be redeemed at par at any time through sophisticated regulation of issuers. The path forward is to bring private-sector innovation safely within the regulatory framework by carefully designing rules for reserve assets, redemption rights, disclosure, anti-money laundering, and user protection.


Shin's concerns are valid, but the global digital finance ecosystem will no longer wait for the public sector to come up with a finished design. The role of central banks should not be to block change, but to incorporate changes already underway into a predictable order.



Seo Byeongyun, Co-CEO of DSRV Labs


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing