Attempted Murder Charge Recognized in Appeals Trial

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

View original image

A man in his sixties, who harbored resentment over being dismissed from his job, visited the nursing hospital where he previously worked while carrying a weapon and caused a disturbance. In the appeals trial, he was found guilty of attempted murder and received a heavier sentence.


On March 26, the Criminal Division 3 of Gwangju District Court (Presiding Judge Kim Ilsu) overturned the original sentence of 8 months in prison and instead sentenced Mr. A (68), who was charged with attempted murder, possession of a weapon in a public place, and inflicting injury, to 3 years in prison.


It was found that Mr. A, dissatisfied with the process of leaving his position at a nursing hospital in Naju, South Jeolla Province in 2023, developed a grudge against the hospital director and planned the crime. In April of last year, he purchased weapons such as a sashimi knife and a small axe at a traditional market, carried them in his vehicle, and visited the hospital several times.


Then, on July 20 of last year, he carried two weapons, went back and forth to the director's office, and instilled fear among hospital staff and patients. He was also charged with causing a two-week injury by repeatedly, about four to five times, forcefully opening and closing his car door even when pedestrians were standing near his vehicle. On the day of the crime, Mr. A fled without meeting the director but was urgently apprehended by police about 40 minutes later after a report was filed.


The first-instance court found him guilty of possessing a weapon in a public place but acquitted him of the attempted murder charge, stating that although he had a motive to kill due to his resentment against the hospital, there was no evidence of any actual threat or physical attack.


However, the appellate court reached a different conclusion. The court explained, "Based on objective facts such as CCTV footage from the scene at the time, it is sufficient to recognize that the defendant carried out preparatory acts for murder," thus overturning the original verdict of not guilty for attempted murder.



The court further stated, "Although the degree of harm is not severe, the defendant has consistently denied the crime with implausible claims from the investigation stage through the appeals trial, and this was taken into account comprehensively in determining the sentence."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing