[Law & Story] Why a Precedent Change on Criminal Contingency Fees Is Necessary
The Entrenchment of Distorted, High Upfront Retainers Has Severe Consequences
Violation of the Principle of Private Autonomy and Freedom of Contract
The Supreme Court Must Revise Its Precedent Out of Touch With Reality
A Constitutional Complaint Should Be Filed to Assess Unconstitutionality
"Neither Confucius nor Jesus ever said that people should strive even if there is no incentive."
This statement was made during a forum on criminal contingency fees held at the National Assembly on March 23. In 2015, the Supreme Court's Grand Bench ruled that even without a contingency fee agreement, lawyers are obligated to diligently perform their delegated work, and declared all criminal contingency fee agreements invalid. Most lawyers responded by saying this was akin to "the words of Confucius."
Recently, it has come to light that an appellate court at the Seoul Central District Court issued a ruling directly challenging the Supreme Court's precedent regarding criminal contingency fees, raising speculation over whether the Supreme Court's stance might change.
The previous Supreme Court ruling, which emphasized the public and ethical nature of lawyers and held that all forms of criminal contingency fee agreements are invalid under Article 103 of the Civil Act, contains several issues.
First, regardless of a lawyer's public role, completely banning contingency fee agreements between clients and lawyers in criminal cases solely because they are criminal matters is an excessive restriction on freedom of contract, violating the constitutional principle of private autonomy in a capitalist society.
This is not unique to suspects or defendants under investigation. Defendants in civil cases facing the loss of their entire assets or parties to administrative litigation who could lose their sole means of livelihood due to business license cancellation are equally desperate when hiring lawyers. This is why the lower court's observation that "the problem lies in excessive fee agreements that exploit the client's dire situation, not in contingency fee agreements themselves" is persuasive.
Most importantly, while the Supreme Court hoped for positive effects by changing its precedent, such effects have been minimal. On the other hand, the negative side effects caused by the distorted structure of criminal case representation have grown so severe that they can no longer be ignored.
After the Supreme Court decision, it became common practice for lawyers to demand higher upfront retainers from the outset, in anticipation of not being able to receive contingency fees later. As a result, former judges and prosecutors or lawyers at large law firms, leveraging their superior bargaining power, could charge high retainers, while young lawyers or those at small and medium-sized law firms were discouraged from taking on criminal cases at all. Ultimately, suspects and victims with limited financial means now find it even more difficult to receive adequate legal assistance in criminal cases than before.
Even if a lawyer's work has a public aspect, lawyers are still independent business operators or wage earners. Expecting them to always do their utmost regardless of the presence or absence of a contingency fee goes against basic human nature. In fact, this is supported by empirical data.
Professor Jiinyup Jee of Dongguk University’s Department of Economics analyzed verdicts from approximately 157,000 cases handled by 1,070 lawyers and found that, after the 2015 Grand Bench decision, the criminal case win rate for the same lawyers was 6.2 percentage points lower than in civil cases. In a survey of about 1,000 lawyers, results showed that the time spent on criminal work decreased after the ruling invalidating criminal contingency fees, and the rate of appeals in criminal cases also dropped, indicating an overall decline in the quality of legal representation by defense counsel.
The background of the Supreme Court’s decision is also questionable. At the time, the Supreme Court did not disclose the referral to the Grand Bench or hold public hearings, but instead rendered a unanimous decision suddenly one day. There were suspicions that the ruling had been planned months in advance as a political move to pressure the Korean Bar Association’s leadership, who opposed the creation of an appeals court, and to curry favor with the Blue House. This was not mere suspicion: former Korean Bar Association President Ha Changwoo revealed as an official witness in the "judicial power abuse" case that he personally confirmed documents seized by prosecutors from the court administration office and exposed these facts.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
If the Supreme Court does not voluntarily change its position—which not only goes against human nature and raises serious concerns about infringing the constitutional freedom of contract, but, above all, ignores market realities—then filing a "constitutional complaint" with the Constitutional Court to seek a ruling on its unconstitutionality may be a viable solution.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.