Five Constitutional Law Experts Express Differing Views

"Exclusion Must Be Clearly Stated in the Law" - Supportive

"Remedies for Appeal Exist, So Not Subject to Complaint" - Opposed

Can warrant hearings and detention orders be subject to constitutional complaints? As the Constitutional Court has begun its legal review on this issue, five constitutional law experts interviewed by this publication were divided in their opinions. The crux of the matter is whether warrants and detention orders should be considered as “separate, independent trials.” Academic interpretations diverged on this point.

Are Detention and Warrants Also Subject to Constitutional Complaints?... Constitutional Court Faces 'Trial Boundaries' Dilemma View original image

According to the legal community on March 30, Article 68, Paragraph 1 of the Constitutional Court Act provides that a constitutional complaint may be filed only against a “finalized court decision.” Specifically, this applies when a court’s ruling has violated fundamental rights due to improper procedures, or when it is clear that the ruling violates the Constitution or the law. In order to prevent abuse of constitutional complaints against court decisions, the principle of subsidiarity is in place, requiring that all other available legal remedies be exhausted before filing a complaint. The Constitutional Court has not yet reached a clear conclusion on this matter. The court’s position is that a concrete determination will be made and released through a panel decision should an actual case be filed.


◆Is a Warrant a Separate Trial?= The key issue is where the “boundaries of a trial” lie. Perspectives on this differ somewhat. Roh Hee-beom, an attorney and former Constitutional Research Officer, stated, “A court’s trial includes rulings, decisions, and orders, so (warrants and detention orders) are covered as well.” However, he prefaced this by saying, “If there are remedies available under other laws, those procedures must be exhausted first.” Jang Youngsoo, a professor at Korea University Law School, argued, “If the intention was to exclude warrants and detention orders from constitutional complaints, this should have been explicitly stated in the law, rather than left to judicial interpretation.”


On the other hand, Jung Taeho, a professor at Kyung Hee University Law School, said, “A key issue is whether a warrant hearing should be viewed as being absorbed into subsequent criminal trial proceedings, or as a separate trial that can be independently challenged.” Choi Seunghwan, an attorney at Barun Law LLC, commented, “Since there are already remedies available to contest the execution of detention orders and warrants, it appears that the warrant hearing itself is not subject to constitutional complaints.” He added, “As there are systems like quasi-appeals already in place, the principle of subsidiarity would prevent filing a constitutional complaint regarding the execution of warrants.”



◆The Nature of Warrant and Detention Order Proceedings Must Be Considered= Kim Jinhwan, an attorney at Klass Hangyeol Law LLC and a member of the Constitutional Practice Research Society under the Constitutional Court, said, “Both proceedings constitute the exercise of public authority that restricts citizens’ fundamental rights, so their judicial nature must be taken into account.” However, he noted, “Warrant hearings are intermediate proceedings, not final judicial decisions, so there may be an issue as to whether it is appropriate for the Constitutional Court to intervene.” Professor Jung pointed out that, in the case of “detention orders,” because immediate appeal is possible, if all remedies have been exhausted and relief is still not granted—such that the decision is final—there would be no reason to treat it differently from other court decisions subject to constitutional complaints.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing