"Don't Bring Children During Rush Hour"... Debate Erupts Over Notorious 'Hell Train' Line 9 Express
"Impossible to Yield," Users Say
Calls Grow for Fundamental Solutions to Line 9's Hellish Congestion
A heated debate has erupted online over 'child accompaniment' on the Seoul Subway Line 9 express train, which is notorious as the "hell train" during rush hours. Some users are urging parents to refrain from boarding with children due to safety concerns, while others argue that such demands are excessive, leading to a back-and-forth exchange of opinions.
Safety training is being conducted inside the station of Line 9. The Asia Business Daily DB.
View original imageThe controversy began on March 23, when an individual posted on social media, saying, "Please do not board the Line 9 express with children during rush hour." The poster argued, "It's hard enough for adults to endure, and for children, it could easily lead to a major accident." He further emphasized, "Choosing the express train over the regular train is even more dangerous."
This post was rapidly shared, attracting hundreds of comments. Users who empathized pointed out the extreme congestion of the Line 9 express. One commenter said, "You have to squeeze in just to get on, and for shorter people, it's almost suffocating." Another shared, "The chest pressure was so severe that I had to get off midway and even vomited." Additional comments included, "You can't even move inside the train," "If you can't hold onto the handle, you just get pushed around," and "It's virtually impossible to protect a child when even adults struggle to keep their balance."
On the other hand, some argued that the demand not to board with children is unrealistic. These users pointed out, "Telling parents not to board with children ignores the reality," and added, "Parents also have no other choice in such situations." There were also opinions that, "Rather than blaming the act of boarding with children itself, a culture of consideration and yielding should come first."
A controversy has arisen online regarding 'child accompaniment' on the Seoul Subway Line 9 express train, notorious for its "hell train" status during rush hours. The photo is unrelated to the specific content of the article. Photo by Jinhyung Kang aymsdream@
View original imageAs the controversy grew, more attention was drawn to the fact that the core of the issue is not 'individual choices' but 'structural congestion.' Despite Line 9 express trains being so overcrowded during rush hour that they have earned the nickname "hell train," critics say the commuting environment has not seen significant improvement. Some users pointed out, "It's a problem when you cannot even offer your seat to a newborn," adding, "At this level, it's not just a safety concern—it’s a systemic issue." There are also calls for fundamental solutions, such as "increasing the number of trains" or "improving train intervals."
"200% Congestion" Line 9 Surpasses Its Carrying Capacity
According to data from Seoul Metro and the Seoul Metropolitan Government, the congestion level of the Line 9 express train during morning rush hour is known to reach around 180 to 200%. A congestion level of 100% means all seats are taken and passengers are standing, while exceeding 150% is considered a stage where physical contact is unavoidable and movement becomes difficult. At close to 200%, passengers are packed in so tightly that the risk of safety accidents rises sharply. This situation is further exacerbated by the system in which both express and regular trains operate on Line 9, concentrating more passengers onto the express trains. As a result, specific trains become even more overcrowded, intensifying the overall congestion.
According to data from Seoul Metro and the Seoul Metropolitan Government, the congestion level of the Line 9 express train during the morning rush hour is known to reach around 180 to 200%. A congestion level of 100% means all seats are occupied and passengers are standing, while exceeding 150% is considered a stage where physical contact is inevitable and movement becomes difficult. Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang aymsdream@
View original imageOther major subway lines also experience severe congestion during rush hours, but the level on Line 9 is comparatively higher. Line 2 sees congestion levels of 150 to 170% around the Gangnam and Jamsil sections, Line 4 sees 140 to 160% between Sadang and Hyehwa, and Line 7 experiences 130 to 150% congestion near Gasan Digital Complex. However, these lines run more frequent trains and benefit from a dispersal effect among passengers, so the issue of passengers concentrating on specific trains is relatively less severe than with the Line 9 express.
"Even Yielding Is Impossible"—Ongoing Conflict Over Safety and the Right to Mobility
Users' firsthand experiences support these statistics. One passenger said, "Line 2 is crowded, but the Line 9 express is on another level. When you ride it yourself, you understand why it's called the 'hell train.'" The problem is that such overcrowding goes beyond simple inconvenience and can pose serious safety risks. Some users pointed out, "It's abnormal that you can't even offer your seat to a newborn," insisting, "This is not a matter of individual choice, but a systemic problem."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
This controversy is considered to have brought the long-standing congestion issue on Line 9 back to the surface, beyond just the question of 'whether to bring children on board.' Photo by Jinhyung Kang aymsdream@
View original imageUltimately, observers say this latest controversy has resurfaced the long-standing congestion issue on Line 9, moving beyond the question of 'whether to board with children.' Among users, there is growing demand for fundamental solutions, such as "increasing the number of trains and improving train intervals" and "reforming the express-focused system." Above all, as the "hell train" situation is repeated every morning and evening, the conflict over safety and the right to mobility persists, and calls are growing for more effective measures to alleviate congestion.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.