[AI Insurance, The Dark Side of Innovation]③No More 'Opaque' AI Claim Denials... Insurers Must Explain Payment Decisions
Major Countries Strengthen AI Transparency
Domestic Guidelines Remain at 'Advisory' Level
Academics: "Reasons for AI Rejection Should Be Disclosed and Human Review Guaranteed"
As insurance companies apply artificial intelligence (AI) throughout their operations, there is a growing call to address 'bias' and 'opacity' in core decision-making processes, including those determining insurance benefit payments. With increasing concerns about declining consumer trust, experts emphasize the need to strengthen transparency—such as disclosing the basis for key decisions—and to improve internal controls and governance structures.
An image depicting an insurance company employee discussing insurance benefit payments and related matters with an insurance policyholder. The Asia Business Daily DB
View original imageEU and US Accelerate Regulatory Overhauls... "Obligation to Explain in Non-Technical Language"
Major countries including the United States and Europe are strengthening regulations on artificial intelligence (AI) and consumer protection standards. ChatGPT generated image
View original imageOverseas, clear steps are being taken to introduce consumer protection mechanisms. The European Union (EU), through the Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act), is strengthening transparency requirements to ensure that consumers can understand the results of AI decisions that may affect them, such as insurance premium calculations or application screenings. The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA), in its "Opinion on AI Governance and Risk Management" published last year, warned that insufficient explanation of AI decision-making processes could lead to biased or discriminatory outcomes. EIOPA stressed, "For decisions that significantly impact consumers, AI systems must explain their influence on the decision in simple and clear non-technical language if requested by the consumer." The intent is that the reasons for AI judgments should be communicated in language that the average consumer can easily understand, rather than in specialized jargon.
In the United States, similar awareness of these issues has led to revised supervisory standards. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the coordinating body for US insurance regulators, has adopted guidelines requiring insurance companies to implement risk management systems when utilizing AI, to prevent consumer harm. Notably, the state of Colorado will begin enforcing the "Colorado AI Act" in June, which imposes obligations on companies to conduct risk management and impact assessments when AI models significantly affect consumers. With this law coming into effect, AI decision-making tools directly related to consumer rights, such as insurance benefit payment determination systems, are expected to become subject to comprehensive regulation.
Concerns Over AI Decision-Making Opacity... Need for Internal Control and Governance Structures
In Korea, a regulatory framework is being established, including the implementation of the Basic Act on Artificial Intelligence this past January. In the financial sector, the Financial Services Commission and the Financial Supervisory Service are set to formally implement the "AI Guidelines for the Financial Sector" and the "AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF)" in line with the new law. These guidelines detail the seven key principles for financial AI, while the AI RMF specifically elaborates on the 'governance principle' among the seven. The focus is on recommending stronger internal controls, such as the establishment of AI decision-making bodies, the operation of dedicated risk management teams, and the implementation of risk assessment and control systems.
However, a major limitation is that the current guidelines alone are insufficient to mandate obligations for explaining the grounds for insurance benefit payment decisions or the basis for AI-driven decisions. While the industry acknowledges these guidelines have a positive effect in highlighting the need for risk management systems, there is criticism that their specificity and enforceability are lacking when it comes to actually preventing consumer disputes.
To address these limitations, experts point out that it is necessary to further enhance transparency in the decision-making process and to improve internal control and governance systems. This is essential to reduce the opacity of AI decision-making and increase consumer acceptance. Seo Jiyong, Professor of Business Administration at Sangmyung University, emphasized, "A system that documents the grounds for payment decisions and discloses them is needed." He added that there should be systematic disclosure of summary information regarding how data is analyzed and how algorithms generate results.
Lee Jooyeol, Professor of Health Administration at Namseoul University, also noted, "Rather than simply presenting AI evaluation scores, it is necessary to establish a framework that explains, with specific causal relationships, which data served as decisive factors in the outcome."
Improving internal management systems within insurers has also been identified as an important task. Professor Seo stated, "It is essential to establish a dedicated AI organization and prepare manuals to respond to risks that may arise during operation," adding that it is crucial to build internal control systems related to risk management.
Son Jaehee, Research Fellow at the Korea Insurance Research Institute, also analyzed, "The AI strategy of the insurance industry is shifting from simply adopting the technology to developing the capacity to operate it responsibly, with a focus on control and verification." She noted the need to "establish proactive risk management systems based on transparency and safety to secure trust."
There are also opinions that stronger consumer protection mechanisms are needed to build trust in AI-based outputs and to establish systems that coexist with consumers. One proposed solution is to strengthen the role of the Chief Consumer Officer (CCO) within company boards. Although only a few firms currently employ a CCO, it is suggested that this practice should be extended to all insurance companies. Professor Seo said, "There is a need to improve corporate governance so that a CCO can be appointed as an internal director and to establish a direct reporting line to the CEO," emphasizing that "holding dual roles with compliance officers should be prohibited to ensure the independence of the CCO."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Additionally, it was suggested that incentive mechanisms linked to financial authorities' evaluation systems are necessary to make such measures a reality. Professor Seo added, "If the Financial Supervisory Service sends the message that it can lower a company's management evaluation grade if the CCO's role is found lacking, this will strengthen the CCO's position within the organization."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.