Urgent Need for Effective Establishment of Directors' Fiduciary Duty to Shareholders
Flexible Split-Off System Preferred Over Blanket Prohibition
Consideration Needed for Growth Drivers of Mid-Sized and Small Companies

There have been calls in the National Assembly for a balanced approach that harmonizes regulatory mechanisms and soft law to resolve the chronic issue of 'subsidiary dual listings,' which has long been criticized for undermining the rights and interests of general shareholders.


Oh Ki-hyung, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, is speaking at the 'Duplicate Listing Issues and Improvement Directions Forum' held on the afternoon of the 25th at the small auditorium of the National Assembly Library. Photo by Lim Chunhan

Oh Ki-hyung, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, is speaking at the 'Duplicate Listing Issues and Improvement Directions Forum' held on the afternoon of the 25th at the small auditorium of the National Assembly Library. Photo by Lim Chunhan

View original image

Nam Gilnam, Senior Research Fellow at the Capital Market Institute, stated at the 'Issues and Improvement Directions of Dual Listing' forum held at the small auditorium of the National Assembly Library on the afternoon of the 25th, "Ultimately, the direction for improving the governance structure of listed companies should focus on controlling shareholders," adding, "Regardless of dual listing, practical measures are needed to resolve conflicts of interest arising from controlling shareholders and to realize the principle of protecting general shareholders."


Examples from major overseas markets were presented as possible directions for improving the domestic market. In Hong Kong, after dual listings of family-owned companies became rampant in the mid-1990s, it was mandated from 1997 that an application must be submitted before a subsidiary can apply for listing, and a principle was established prohibiting dual listings for a single business. In addition, general shareholders of the parent company were ensured not to be left out during the process of subsidiary spin-offs by being given in-kind dividends or preferential rights to new shares of the spun-off subsidiary.


The Tokyo Stock Exchange in Japan has encouraged the dissolution of equity relationships between listed companies through soft law instruments such as corporate governance reports, and has continually pressured parent companies to enhance corporate value for general shareholders of dual-listed subsidiaries. As a result, the number of dual-listed subsidiaries decreased from 324 (9.5%) in 2014 to 216 (5.6%) in 2025. The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq in the United States also significantly strengthened corporate governance requirements with the enactment of the Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act and stricter listing rules in the early 2000s.


Nam explained, "Attracting attractive companies and protecting investors is primarily the responsibility of listing regulations," and added, "Globally, the increasing demand for stable management control in emerging tech companies and demands from investor groups for improved corporate governance are both realities." He continued, "If the director's duty of loyalty to shareholders, which was introduced through amendments to the Commercial Act, can be effectively established, it will be possible to design soft law. We should start with new listing reviews and pursue the gradual resolution of existing dual listing structures."


Jin-Gnam Nam, Senior Research Fellow at the Capital Market Institute, is delivering a presentation at the ‘Issues and Improvement Directions of Dual Listing’ forum held at the National Assembly Library Small Auditorium on the afternoon of the 25th. Photo by Chunhan Lim

Jin-Gnam Nam, Senior Research Fellow at the Capital Market Institute, is delivering a presentation at the ‘Issues and Improvement Directions of Dual Listing’ forum held at the National Assembly Library Small Auditorium on the afternoon of the 25th. Photo by Chunhan Lim

View original image

The government and related institutions have reached a consensus on the need for strict review of dual listings and the principle of shareholder protection. Ko Youngho, Director of Capital Markets at the Financial Services Commission, stated, "If something is listed twice, we determine that investors perceive it as a dual listing. In cases where a vertical controlling-subsidiary relationship exists, we have established the discussion that it can be considered a single entity," emphasizing the need for strict review.


Lim Heungtaek, Deputy Head of the KOSPI Market Division at Korea Exchange, said, "The reason advanced markets have fewer dual listings is that companies genuinely work for their shareholders, and there is a philosophy that companies and shareholders are one and the same," adding, "The listing review will focus on ensuring shareholder interests are clearly protected and that full consent from shareholders can be obtained. We will work to develop guidelines accordingly."


Experts pointed out that the issue is not dual listing itself, but rather the rigidity of institutional limitations. Ji Inyeob, Professor of Economics at Dongguk University, said, "The problem is not dual listing per se, but rather that Korea's rigid spin-off system does not provide shareholders with sufficient choices," adding, "Policy direction should not be to universally prohibit dual listings, but to introduce a more flexible spin-off system that respects companies' growth and capital-raising needs, allowing existing shareholders to move to subsidiaries or continue participating in their growth."


Kim Hyunggyun, Vice President of the Korea Corporate Governance Forum, said, "In the long term, it is desirable to promote the complete conversion of existing dual-listed subsidiaries into wholly owned subsidiaries," adding, "As a principle, all dual listings of subsidiaries should be prohibited. However, if directors, in fulfilling their duty of loyalty to shareholders during the dual listing process, fully explain its necessity and the benefits to all shareholders, and if the proposal is approved at the general meeting of shareholders through a majority vote of minority shareholders, it should be permitted."


There were also opinions highlighting the need for flexible application, taking into account the growth drivers of companies. Ahn Sangjun, Vice President of the Korea Venture Capital Association, stated, "For affiliates of mid-sized and small companies, it is necessary to either exclude them from dual listing reviews or relax such requirements," adding, "Instead of uniform regulation, the independence of subsidiaries and the need for new capital through listing should be considered to protect the growth drivers of small and medium-sized enterprises."



Oh Ki-hyung, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea who chaired the forum, said, "Although various opinions are being raised from different perspectives, such debates are necessary. We need to reduce dual listings, and if we allow them unconditionally, regulatory loopholes will continue to proliferate, so we must continue to discuss standards and principles going forward."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing