The Korea Corporate Governance Forum has strongly objected to SK hynix's efforts to list on a local U.S. stock exchange through the issuance of American Depositary Receipts (ADRs), arguing that this could infringe upon the interests of existing shareholders.


In a statement released on March 25, the Governance Forum said, "While we support the issuance of ADRs, we oppose issuing new shares that would dilute existing shareholders' equity, especially when there is an abundance of surplus cash flow."


The Forum added, "SK hynix is expected to hold 35 trillion won in cash by the end of 2025, and according to estimates by Mirae Asset Securities, even after executing 189 trillion won in capital expenditures and tens of trillions of won in research and development (R&D) investments between 2026 and 2028, the company will generate as much as 672 trillion won in surplus cash flow. Given that the planned scale of ADR issuance is 10 trillion to 15 trillion won, we question why new funding is necessary."


The Forum further stated, "An ADR listing based on the issuance of new shares will serve as a test case for the amended Commercial Act. In line with directors' fiduciary duties to shareholders, the board must thoroughly consider all possible alternatives—including available cash, surplus cash flow, and borrowing—when making major decisions such as issuing new shares, and must select the option that is reasonably expected to maximize proportional shareholder benefits." The statement continued, "Following the final decision, the company must transparently disclose the pros and cons of each alternative and the reasoning behind the final choice, in terms of procedural legitimacy."


Accordingly, the Forum recommended that SK hynix acquire and partially retire 10% to 15% of its total outstanding shares, and list the majority of them in the United States. The Forum pointed out, "For ADRs listed in the U.S. to be sufficiently liquid and included in exchange-traded funds (ETFs), the scale must be at least USD 20 billion to 30 billion." As an example, the Forum cited TSMC's U.S. ADR (TSM): "The TSM ADR alone has a market capitalization of 530 trillion won, and its daily trading volume reaches 7 trillion won—far surpassing SK hynix's recent daily trading volume of 4 trillion won." The Forum explained that an ADR issuance of only 10 trillion to 15 trillion won would lack sufficient liquidity to establish a meaningful presence in the U.S. market.


The Forum also commented, "There are expectations in the securities industry that ADR issuance could result in a valuation on par with Micron, but this is an extremely naive assumption. An ADR listing does not immediately lead to a valuation re-rating; governance improvements must come first for a revaluation of the stock to occur."



Furthermore, the Forum emphasized, "What is urgently needed now is for SK hynix's management and board of directors to work together to reduce governance risks and enhance the company's valuation." The Forum called for: ▲clarifying the principles of capital allocation, ▲strengthening the board's independence by appointing capital market and governance experts to balance the current dominance of professors and Kim & Chang, and ▲addressing shareholders' concerns regarding the company's U.S. artificial intelligence (AI) subsidiary.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing