Council of Europe Human Rights Commissioner Criticizes SNS Regulations in Various Countries

"There Are Other Ways to Address Harmful Online Content"

"Restrictions on Access to Information Possible, But Only Within Necessary Limits"

The Council of Europe's Commissioner for Human Rights has expressed opposition to measures blocking children's access to social networking services (SNS), calling them a "violation of human rights."


Photo for article understanding.

Photo for article understanding.

View original image

According to Yonhap News Agency, on March 24 (local time), Michael O'Flaherty, the Council of Europe’s Commissioner for Human Rights, said in an interview with Politico Europe, "There are other ways to break the curse of harmful online content," adding, "Blocking children from accessing SNS is neither proportional nor necessary."


O'Flaherty, a human rights expert from Ireland, stated, "The discussion on how to protect children from the harms of SNS has rushed straight to 'prohibition' without fully considering other possible alternatives." He further explained, "Children have the right to receive information just like anyone else, so this constitutes a violation of human rights."


These remarks are aimed at recent SNS regulations being implemented in various countries around the world. At the end of last year, Australia became the first country to block SNS account access for those under 16, and similar measures have followed in Brazil and Indonesia, leading to SNS regulations targeting children in different countries. Additionally, European Union (EU) countries such as France, Denmark, and Greece are also moving to introduce age restrictions on SNS access, citing concerns about children's mental health.


Proponents of SNS regulation argue that age restrictions on highly addictive SNS access are essential to protecting children's physical and mental health. Opponents counter that such measures are ineffective and could infringe on privacy rights, as they require online identity verification.


Instagram app photo to help understand the article. Photo by Reuters and Yonhap News Agency

Instagram app photo to help understand the article. Photo by Reuters and Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Commissioner O'Flaherty stated, "Overall, if it helps reduce risks to children, the right to access information may be restricted." However, he emphasized, "Such restrictions must be proportional and necessary." He added, "Before restricting children's access to SNS, the EU should make serious efforts to address illegal and harmful content on these platforms," and criticized that "the Digital Services Act (DSA), which aims to protect children from structural risks on online platforms, is not being enforced strongly enough."



Meanwhile, in South Korea, related legislation is being promoted in the National Assembly or considered at the government level. However, the main government body, the Broadcasting and Media Communications Commission, is focusing more on algorithm restrictions rather than age limits. In a work report to the National Assembly in February, the Commission stated it would "prepare measures to address the overdependence of children and adolescents on SNS" and announced plans to propose an amendment to the Information and Communications Network Act, which will establish new definitions for SNS and algorithms, within the second half of this year.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing