Korea Zinc Chairman Choi Yunbeom Secures Another Term... MBK Also Expands Influence (Comprehensive)
Three-Hour Delay in Opening... Friction From the Start
Board Defended Through Cumulative Voting... Secures Another Term
Board Composition Shifts From 11:4 to 9:5
Too Early to Call It a Complete Victory for Chairman Choi... Legal Disputes Possible
At the regular shareholders' meeting of Korea Zinc, Chairman Choi Yunbeom succeeded in securing another term, effectively defending his management control. However, the Young Poong and MBK Partners alliance also increased the number of directors on their side, expanding their influence. The gap in the number of directors secured by each side has narrowed from seven to four.
At the shareholders' meeting of Korea Zinc held on the 24th at the Koreana Hotel in Jung-gu, Seoul, Chairman Choi was reappointed as an inside director. In addition, Hwang Deoknam, the board chair and a candidate from the company side, also retained his seat on the board. Walter McLaren, a candidate from the U.S. Crucible JV, was newly appointed as a director. From the Young Poong and MBK Partners side, Choi Yeonseok, Vice President of MBK Partners, and Lee Seonsook from Minju Law Firm, among others, joined the board. As a result, the previous board composition of 11 for Korea Zinc and four for Young Poong and MBK Partners has been reorganized into nine versus five.
Three-Hour Delay in Opening... Tension Over Number of Directors to Be Appointed
The shareholders' meeting on this day was marked by friction from the start. Originally scheduled to begin at 9 a.m., the meeting was delayed as the process of verifying duplicate proxies continued, with entrance only beginning at 9:54 a.m. Further delays ensued, and the meeting finally commenced around noon—three hours behind schedule.
The tense atmosphere was also palpable outside the meeting venue. Members of the Korea Zinc labor union, who had traveled from the Onsan smelter, staged a protest at the entrance of the Koreana Hotel, holding placards with messages such as “MBK, it's time to step down” and “We will protect the state-owned Korea Zinc until the end.” Since the outbreak of the management dispute between Korea Zinc and the Young Poong–MBK Partners alliance, the labor union has consistently supported the current management of Korea Zinc.
There was fierce rivalry over the method for appointing directors at the shareholders' meeting. The key issue was how and how many of the six directors whose terms were expiring would be reappointed.
The Young Poong–MBK Partners alliance proposed appointing six directors, while Yumi Development, representing Korea Zinc’s management, proposed appointing five. The Young Poong–MBK Partners alliance believed that appointing six directors would result in a 3-to-3 split under the cumulative voting system, thereby narrowing the gap in the number of directors. They also aimed to secure more director seats by dispersing votes if necessary to defend Chairman Choi. The cumulative voting system allows shareholders to exercise a number of votes equal to the number of shares they own multiplied by the number of directors to be elected, enabling them to concentrate votes on specific candidates.
On the other hand, Chairman Choi’s side proposed appointing five directors, and electing the remaining one as an audit committee member at a future extraordinary shareholders' meeting. By reducing the number of candidates subject to cumulative voting to five, they anticipated minimizing the dispersal of votes, allowing Chairman Choi’s side to secure three seats and the Young Poong–MBK Partners side two. Although the proposal to appoint six directors received a majority of votes, the five-director plan passed in accordance with the principle that the proposal with the most votes prevails. In the subsequent director election, Chairman Choi’s side secured three seats, including one from the U.S. JV. With this result, Chairman Choi succeeded in being reappointed and retained the majority on the board.
Too Early to Call It a 'Complete Victory' for Chairman Choi... Possibility of Legal Disputes Remains
The regular shareholders' meeting of Korea Zinc is taking place on the 24th at the Koreana Hotel in Jung-gu, Seoul. Korea Zinc
View original imageAlthough Chairman Choi’s side succeeded in defending management control, some say it was not a complete victory. This is because the gap between the two sides on the board has narrowed, and the influence of the U.S. joint venture, Crucible JV, has grown. As the Young Poong–MBK Partners side is also working hard to win over U.S. investors, future board confrontations are drawing attention.
Opposition from institutional investors, including the National Pension Service, is also a significant blow for Chairman Choi. The National Pension Service, which holds a 5.2% stake, abstained from voting on the proposals for Chairman Choi and Board Chair Hwang Deoknam from the company side, as well as accountant Park Byungwook from Cheong Accounting Firm, who was nominated by the Young Poong–MBK Partners side. In the midst of fierce competition, this effectively put a brake on the proceedings. The National Pension Service explained its abstention by stating, “This is because the candidates in question have records of damaging corporate value or infringing on shareholder rights.”
The conflict between the two sides over the application of the cumulative voting system also leaves room for possible lawsuits. In the cumulative voting system, the number of votes is multiplied by the number of directors to be elected. However, some foreign institutional investors exercised their voting rights only for specific candidates. Depending on whether these unexercised voting rights are simply recognized as is, or redistributed proportionally, the outcome may differ.
The Young Poong–MBK Partners side argued that changing the standard suddenly on the day of the shareholders' meeting was not just a matter of interpretation but an attempt to directly influence the outcome. Their representative stated, “At last year's shareholders' meeting, Korea Zinc did not redistribute the unexercised voting rights in such situations, instead counting only the votes that were actually cast. However, at this year's meeting, they reversed the previous standard and claimed that a ‘pro rata’ method—proportionally redistributing even the under-voted rights—should be applied.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
In contrast, Korea Zinc’s legal representative countered, “When foreigners exercise voting rights, they often do not fully recognize the cumulative voting system and end up exercising only a portion of the voting rights available to them. If this is due to structural or systemic issues, not their own intent, then it is right to correct it.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.