Anyone Can Run in Any District if Registered 60 Days Before the Election

Mercenaries Claiming to Be Locals in Places They've Only Briefly Passed Through

Communities Welcome "Powerful" Outsiders Sent from the Center

Local Autonomy in N

Any South Korean citizen aged 18 or older can run in local elections as long as they are registered as a resident in the area at least 60 days prior to election day. Since it is natural for local figures to run in local elections, the Public Official Election Act does not specifically require further qualifications. Ironically, this "60 days prior to election day" requirement has become a symbol of the underdevelopment and central dependency of local autonomy in South Korea. It is now a familiar sight to see outsiders appearing and introducing themselves just before the election. The phenomenon of high-profile politicians running for metropolitan governments where they have no prior connection is another example of abnormality becoming normalized.


Ahead of the 9th nationwide local elections scheduled for June 3, officials from the Gwangju Election Commission conducted a mock vote count at the Kim Daejung Convention Center in Seo-gu, Gwangju in February. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Ahead of the 9th nationwide local elections scheduled for June 3, officials from the Gwangju Election Commission conducted a mock vote count at the Kim Daejung Convention Center in Seo-gu, Gwangju in February. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The "Town Hall Meeting" is often cited as the essence of American democracy. Alexis de Tocqueville, in his book "Democracy in America," described how New England residents would discuss and solve local issues together, calling it a "school of democracy." Through this process of collective deliberation, people develop affection for their communities, learn to compromise, and make concessions. They also acquire the skills of decision-making for coexistence. Most importantly, mature democracy is possible when local representatives are nurtured and eventually grow into national leaders. To become a representative, one must take root in the community and be recognized for their achievements and abilities. In the United States, outsiders who suddenly appear during elections without any prior involvement in the community are called "carpetbaggers," a term laced with contempt for those who "beg" to become representatives.


In contrast, things are different in South Korea. Looking at the people running in local elections, it is often doubtful whether they are truly local residents. Some may claim the area as their hometown, but many have spent most of their lives elsewhere. Having worked at the Blue House, served as high-level central government officials, or gained notoriety in the media, these candidates emphasize their own competence. Local residents also seem to favor such people, thinking they will bring in ample budgets and spur significant development for the area. Thus, management of the community is democratically (?) entrusted to outsiders. Many regions across the country recruit such "mercenaries" during elections, leading to the peculiar spectacle of outsiders competing against each other in what can be described as a "bittersweet" scene—neither laughable nor lamentable.


Due to the long-standing de facto political monopoly of the two-party system in South Korea, many people have come to readily accept this central dependency in local elections. They believe that having a powerful politician is better for their community. Since 1992, for nearly 35 years of local elections, local autonomy has failed to take root for this very reason. Why is that? Because there is local favoritism where it shouldn't exist, and a lack of backbone where there should be. Every region has numerous ordinances that prioritize their own interests. Amid this ultra-level parochialism, the 230 local governments engage in trading favoritism and vested interests, which are also used for political vote-gathering. In this environment, so-called powerful politicians have an advantage. As a result, outsiders who suddenly appear are sometimes valued more highly than local residents lacking such connections.


The reality that local governments have almost no actual authority even after 30 years of local autonomy also contributes to this situation. The overwhelming fiscal dependence on the central government, and the existence of ordinances notwithstanding, make it nearly impossible to establish genuinely differential or effective systems. Even metropolitan governments are mostly tasked with delegated duties from the central government, and basic local governments can count the number of actual autonomous responsibilities they have. At this point, local autonomy amounts to little more than creating plausible positions in the political marketplace. With so little to actually decide for themselves, genuine town hall meetings cannot emerge in local government.


On the 30th of last month, at the 3rd Executive Committee Meeting of the Gyeonggi Province Democratic Party held at the Gyeonggi Provincial Assembly in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province, the Democratic Party gubernatorial primary candidates for the 9th nationwide simultaneous local elections in Gyeonggi Province are shouting "Fighting". From left to right are candidates Dongyeon Kim, Mi Ae Chu, Junho Han. Photo by Yonhap News

On the 30th of last month, at the 3rd Executive Committee Meeting of the Gyeonggi Province Democratic Party held at the Gyeonggi Provincial Assembly in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province, the Democratic Party gubernatorial primary candidates for the 9th nationwide simultaneous local elections in Gyeonggi Province are shouting "Fighting". From left to right are candidates Dongyeon Kim, Mi Ae Chu, Junho Han. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image
On the 1st, candidates pledged a fair primary at the 9th simultaneous nationwide local elections People's Power Daegu mayoral primary fair election pledge ceremony held at the People's Power Daegu City Party. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

On the 1st, candidates pledged a fair primary at the 9th simultaneous nationwide local elections People's Power Daegu mayoral primary fair election pledge ceremony held at the People's Power Daegu City Party. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

At its core, the problem lies with vested interests in central politics. As can be inferred from the recent Democratic Party nomination bribery scandal, local district National Assembly members wield enormous power in candidate nominations for their districts in local elections. Ironically, those at the top of the local political pyramid have no residency requirement to run for the National Assembly. Anyone over 18 can be nominated in any electoral district across the country. Under the name of "strategic nominations," people with no connection to the area are used like chess pieces to create matchups designed to win, and the media finds it entertaining to broadcast these matchups.


But let's think for a moment. Can it really be called grassroots democracy when people with no local connection exercise nomination power to select local representatives? As a result, South Korean local politics is driven by strange incentives. The term "local autonomy" is applied to over 200 local government divisions, creating numerous positions for heads and council members, which in turn generates just as many political posts. Relying on the local sentiment that favors high-profile figures, central political elites are nominated and sent down to run for these posts. Career management is also easy. If their party comes to power, a brief stint at the Blue House or in a public agency is enough to add a prestigious credential to their resume. True self-governance requires institutionalizing bottom-up nominations and having the central party step back, but there is no intention to do so. Tax, fiscal, and regulatory powers should also be fully devolved to local governments, but that too remains a distant prospect. Outwardly, local autonomy is touted, but central politicians are reluctant to let local governments slip from their grasp, fearing uncertainty in the political game of increasing their own ranks.


The root of South Korea's political failure lies here. People who have not internalized the lessons of democracy in town halls, but have instead learned politics as a game of conflict and strategy, now run the country's politics. If politicians had a solid local base, they would be able to voice their opinions on various issues with confidence, but when nominations are in the hands of representatives or the central party, "mouth-shut" politics prevails. Politics severed from community life—where dialogue and compromise are replaced by a strategy focused solely on our side's victory—becomes the norm. This stands in stark contrast to advanced democracies like the United States and the United Kingdom, where the authority of local residents and party members is firmly established.


The task before us is clear. To stop "mercenary politics," a complete shift to bottom-up nominations is urgently needed. Central politics should not intervene at all. Whether in local or National Assembly elections, candidates should be nominated by local residents or party members. It is time to end the odd practice of electing someone as a local representative who only became a resident a few months before the election. Even the smallest local electoral district has tens of thousands of residents. If we cannot select our own representative from among tens of thousands, local autonomy is merely a facade, and political reform will remain out of reach. So let's take a look this time: how many true local residents are actually running in our local elections?



[Lee Hyukwoo's Beyond the Frame] Remove the Red Carpet for 'Mercenary Politics' View original image

Hyeokwoo Lee, Professor of Public Administration at Paichai University (Chairman of the Regulation Monitoring Committee at Good Regulation Citizens’ Forum)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing