[Public Voices] Jongmyo: The Shadow of Development Cast Over a 600-Year Heritage
An Isolated Heritage Losing Its Identity
Seoul’s Legacy for Future Generations Must Be Considered
Seoul is a global metropolis ranked 6th in the Global City Competitiveness Index. While skyscrapers and cutting-edge infrastructure are rapidly transforming the city’s appearance, the true driving force behind Seoul’s status as a world-class city lies in its deeply layered history. People from around the globe are drawn to Seoul not merely for its modernity. The coexistence of 600 years of Joseon Dynasty history with the present city, this unique stratification of time, is Seoul’s most powerful competitive edge.
At the heart of this stands Jongmyo. Jongmyo is more than just the royal ancestral shrine of the Joseon Dynasty; it is the architectural embodiment of a Confucian worldview and an understanding of natural order expressed spatially. Its layout, which follows a linear hierarchy while harmonizing with the natural terrain, reflects a philosophy that seeks to place humans and nature, ancestors and descendants, within a unified order. In this respect, Jongmyo is not simply a historical site, but a place where an entire ideology and civilization are condensed.
However, the value of Jongmyo is not confined to the buildings within its walls. The spatial flow extending from Bukhansan Mountain, passing through Eungbong and Jongmyo, and continuing to Namsan Mountain—the grand geographical and visual axis—is a key element for fully understanding Jongmyo. This axis is not just a matter of views; it is a symbolic order connecting the natural and human worlds, and forms the foundation of the spatial structure of Joseon’s urban planning.
This is precisely what UNESCO highlighted in 1995 when it designated Jongmyo as a World Cultural Heritage site. At that time, UNESCO made it clear that the construction of high-rise buildings that could negatively impact the views from Jongmyo should be restricted. This is more than a simple recommendation; it is a core condition for maintaining Jongmyo’s “outstanding universal value.” Preserving the visual corridor from Jongmyo’s main hall to Namsan is both a commitment to the international community and a basic principle of heritage conservation.
Nevertheless, there have recently been calls to ease regulations and permit high-density development in central areas, including around Jongmyo. Some cite the constitutional protection of property rights and the principle of proportionality, criticizing the World Heritage Impact Assessment system as an excessive regulation. However, these arguments stem partly from an insufficient understanding of the true nature of heritage protection systems.
The World Heritage Impact Assessment is not an unrestricted regulation arbitrarily applied by administrative authorities. It is a limited yet essential safeguard, activated only when a project is likely to have a significant negative impact on the value of a World Heritage site. It is not a system designed to completely suppress development, but rather a mechanism to seek a reasonable balance within the boundaries that do not harm the essential value of the heritage.
High-rise buildings that block the views from Jongmyo are not simply a matter of changing the landscape. They sever a spatial order that has formed over centuries and fundamentally damage the meaning and value system of the cultural heritage. Any temporary development gains accrue to a select few, but the damaged heritage cannot be restored. In this sense, regulation is not a measure to restrict private interests, but the minimum social mechanism to prevent irreversible public loss.
Leading cities around the world already firmly implement these principles. France has actively worked to expand buffer zones to protect the historic landscape along the Seine in Paris. In London, the view corridors ensuring visibility of St. Paul’s Cathedral’s dome are strictly managed, and all development proceeds on this basis. These cities clearly recognize that preserving cultural heritage landscapes is essential for maintaining urban dignity and ensuring long-term competitiveness.
Seoul now faces the same question: Will it prioritize short-term economic gains, or will it preserve its identity as a city where history and landscape are alive? Reckless high-rise development around Jongmyo is not just an issue of urban planning; it is a choice that will determine what kind of city Seoul will ultimately become.
If Jongmyo is reduced to an “isolated heritage” lost amid a forest of buildings, this will not only mar the landscape but also result in the loss of the city’s identity. Conversely, if the view corridors and landscape axes of Jongmyo are fully preserved, Seoul can further solidify its unique position as a global city where the past and present coexist.
Protecting cultural heritage is not merely about preserving the past. It is about shaping the value of the future city and making a responsible choice about what kind of city will be passed down to the next generation. Based on this awareness, the National Heritage Administration and Seoul Metropolitan Government must implement the World Heritage Impact Assessment strictly and transparently.
The landscape of Jongmyo is not the property of any individual or group. It is a shared asset that should be enjoyed by all humanity, not just the people of Korea. The choices we make now will determine the future of this space, which holds 600 years of history.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Shin Woongjoo, Professor of Architecture, Chosun University
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.