How Should Preliminary Review for Judicial Petitions Be Conducted?
With the implementation of the judicial petition system, a total of 118 judicial petition cases were filed with the Constitutional Court as of March 19. To address the surge in cases, the Constitutional Court and academic experts convened to discuss how to conduct “preliminary review.” There were differing opinions, with some suggesting that a designated panel of three judges could make decisions during the preliminary review process, while others argued that the participation of as many constitutional justices as possible would be preferable.
On the afternoon of March 20, the Constitutional Research Society—an organization under the Constitutional Court—held an internal presentation at the Constitutional Court’s main auditorium in Jaedong, Seoul, under the theme “Constitutional Petitions for Trials and the Preliminary Review System.”
Attorney Jinhan Kim (29th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute) from Klass Hangyeol Law Firm, a former constitutional researcher, delivered the presentation. He examined the “preliminary review system” of the German Federal Constitutional Court and the “case selection system” of the United States Supreme Court, highlighting the direction that Korea’s Constitutional Court should pursue.
He addressed the German practice of assigning preliminary reviews to a chamber (Kammer) rather than a full senate (Senat). Kim explained, “In the chamber, the process relies heavily on the presiding judge’s opinion, which leads to differing standards depending on each judge. The procedures are primarily document-based rather than conducted through in-person deliberations. This results in an unconvincing preliminary review practice and causes unnecessarily intense legality reviews, ultimately undervaluing the significance of the preliminary review.” He cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s concrete and rigorous face-to-face discussion method—the so-called “Rule of Four,” which requires agreement from four justices to select a case—as a positive alternative.
He also emphasized the need for the U.S. Supreme Court’s “issue statement system,” where petitioners must specify the issues in their petitions. In this system, the actual subject of judgment is not the lower court decision itself, but rather the specific issues identified by the petitioner.
Kim criticized the inefficiency of the German-style claim structure. He pointed out that there are no mechanisms to limit the specific issues, allowing parties to raise every possible argument. If a case passes the preliminary review, the bench must consider all these issues. As a result, representatives attempt to raise as many issues as possible to increase their chances of passing, which ultimately leads to inefficiency in the proceedings.
Kim further noted, “The most significant conflict in Korea right now is whether the judicial petition is primarily for ‘protecting individual rights’ or for ‘system operation’ in line with the Court’s role and mission. If the focus is on individual rights, it could become a reality that matches public concerns about the system serving as a de facto fourth instance.” He added that in order to protect the Constitutional Court’s function and fulfill its intended mission, the Court needs to free itself from the pressure to remedy every fundamental rights violation in all cases.
Various discussions continued in the following panel session.
Gwanghyun Jeong (27th class), Professor at Hanyang University Law School, proposed “jurisdictional bifurcation.” He suggested that the Constitutional Court should exclusively handle direct fundamental rights violations, while indirect cases based on violations of procedural law, such as breaches of litigation rules, could be handled by establishing a so-called “Constitutional Division” within the Supreme Court.
Kyoungmi Seo (33rd class), Professor at Sungkyunkwan University Law School, recommended a “strict interpretation of the subsidiarity requirement” as an alternative. She reasoned that the current amended law’s grounds for filing are insufficient to effectively screen constitutionally significant cases. Professor Seo stated, “We should consider introducing the German Federal Constitutional Court’s formal and substantive subsidiarity principles as a matter of legal interpretation in Korea.”
Jaekang Lee (41st class), a constitutional researcher, also noted, “When judicial petition filings surge, there is a need to process them swiftly. Given the Constitutional Court’s staffing limitations, it is important to clarify admissibility requirements during preliminary review to dismiss certain cases, and to assess the seriousness of cases before referring them to the full bench.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Reporter Kim Jisoo, The Law Times
※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.