"No Rational Basis for Excluding Maternal Grandparents from Condolence Supplies"

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea has determined that it is discriminatory for a public corporation to apply different standards for employee family allowances and condolence supplies based on birth order and a patrilineal family concept.


National Human Rights Commission of Korea, Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

National Human Rights Commission of Korea, Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On March 23, the Commission announced that it had recommended improvements to the system, stating that it is discriminatory for a public corporation to operate different standards for family allowances and condolence supplies without a reasonable basis. The Commission recommended that the corporation revise its regulations so that family allowances are provided regardless of birth order and condolence supplies are also provided equally in the event of the death of maternal grandparents.


Under the current policy, the corporation has provided family allowances to eldest sons and daughters even if they do not actually live with their parents, whereas other children, such as second-born sons or daughters, have been required to meet a “cohabitation” condition in order to receive the allowance. Thus, even if the same parents are being supported, the criteria for receiving the allowance have differed depending on birth order. As for condolence supplies, they have only been provided in the event of the death of paternal grandparents, but not for maternal grandparents.


The corporation explained, “Because family living arrangements and support structures are diverse, it is difficult to judge based solely on cohabitation as registered in the resident registration,” and added, “The standards are based on the traditional role of eldest sons and daughters in taking responsibility for the family, as well as actual support circumstances.” In addition, the corporation noted that these standards are set according to a labor-management collective agreement, and that the criteria for condolence supplies are also unavoidable due to budget constraints.


However, the Commission’s Committee for the Correction of Discrimination judged that “in modern society, family structures and support arrangements are diverse, and it is difficult to assume that parental support is the exclusive responsibility of a particular child.” The committee stated, “Basing the provision of allowances solely on birth order is not directly related to the actual support relationship.”



The committee further pointed out, “Both paternal and maternal grandparents are considered direct lineal ascendants under the Civil Act. Providing condolence supplies only for paternal grandparents constitutes discriminatory treatment based on a patrilineal standard.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing