Foreign Suspect Acquitted in Both First and Second Trials

Two Main Suspects Fled the Country Shortly After the Incident

The murder case that occurred 28 years ago at a wastewater treatment subcontractor in Seo-gu, Incheon, has become a mystery after the suspect was acquitted in both the first and second trials.


According to Yonhap News on March 21, the Criminal Division 1 of the Seoul High Court Incheon Branch (Presiding Judge Jeong Seungkyu) recently delivered the same verdict as the lower court, finding defendant A not guilty of murder. At the time, A was a foreign worker at the plant and was accused of killing B, a deputy manager at the same company, who was 35 years old at the time.


'Wastewater Tank Murder' from 28 Years Ago Remains Unsolved as Suspect Acquitted in Both Trials View original image

B, who went missing on December 17, 1997, was found dead about a month later on January 22 of the following year in an underground wastewater tank at the company’s facility. He was wrapped in a burlap sack with a 20-kg motor tied to his chest, and also had a 5-cm depressed wound on his head. The autopsy revealed the cause of death as both drowning and asphyxiation due to wastewater sludge.


At the time, the pathway to the wastewater tank was cluttered with pipes and oxygen generators, and some sections were only 15 to 20 cm wide. Police concluded that it would have been nearly impossible for a single person to move an adult male burdened with a heavy motor, and thus estimated that at least two people had participated in disposing of the body.


The investigation narrowed its focus to three foreign workers, including A, who were employed at the plant. Statements from company personnel indicated that B, often drunk, would come to the dormitory and verbally or physically abuse these workers. According to colleagues, just two days before B’s disappearance, he slapped A on the cheek, saying, "It's night shift, but you're sleeping instead of working."


By the time B’s body was belatedly discovered, all three foreign workers, including A, had vanished after gathering their passports and belongings. Of these, C and D, who were suspected as the main culprits, fled to their home country on December 30, 1997, 13 days after B’s disappearance, and A also hastily left Korea on January 20 of the following year. After C left the country, it was reported that he confessed in a call with an acquaintance, saying, "He tormented us too much, so I had no choice but to kill him. The other two left in Korea (A and another) also know everything about this case."


As all prime suspects fled, the case seemed destined to remain an unsolved mystery. However, 27 years later, in July 2024, the case resurfaced when A, who had been on the run and listed on an Interpol red notice, was arrested at a foreign airport.


In February last year, A was forcibly extradited to Korea and brought to trial on murder charges, but was acquitted in the first trial. At the time, the court stated, "There is no direct evidence to prove that the defendant killed or conspired to kill the victim."


During the appeal, prosecutors argued that even if A did not personally commit the murder, he should still be punished for aiding and abetting the crime, as he was on night duty on the day of the incident and took no action despite being aware of the crime. However, the appellate court also found A not guilty.


The court noted that while it was suspicious that A abandoned his wages and fled in haste, there was no direct evidence proving the crime. The bench further explained, "Investigators searched the suspected crime scene twice, but found neither the murder weapon nor any traces of the victim's blood. There was no evidence on the defendant’s work clothes or shoes, nor on the victim’s body." The court added, "Unlike C and D, there is no clear evidence that the defendant harbored enough resentment to kill the victim, and it cannot be ruled out that he fled simply out of fear of being implicated after learning of the victim’s death."


Regarding the charge of aiding and abetting murder, the appellate panel also considered the possibility that the defendant may not have been aware of the crime at all. The court stated, "As some witness testimony suggests, the defendant may have fallen asleep during his usual night shift and been completely unaware of the crime. It cannot be concluded that the defendant knowingly failed to rescue the victim and thereby assisted in the crime," and dismissed the prosecution’s appeal.



The whereabouts of C and D remain unknown to this day.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing