Recognizing Achievements, But Bearing Losses Personally
Drawing the Line on Public Funding for Investment Failures
"Transitioning from Easy Finance to High-Risk Investment"

There has been a suggestion that in order to revitalize productive finance, a sophisticated incentive structure that includes both rewards and penalties is necessary. Given that the ability to select promising companies is crucial for delivering results, it was also noted that a performance-based compensation system is needed to motivate the employees in charge. However, it was emphasized that the principle of self-responsibility should apply to investment failures, and the injection of public funds is not desirable.


The Success of Productive Finance Hinges on Company Selection and Incentive Structures View original image

Kim Seokki, Senior Research Fellow at the Korea Institute of Finance, said on March 21, "To revitalize productive finance, we must design a sophisticated incentive structure that includes not only bonuses, but also both rewards and penalties." This aligns with the main points of his recently published report, "Banks' Selection Capabilities and Incentives for Revitalizing Productive Finance."


Productive finance is a core policy agenda of the Lee Jaemyung administration. It refers to a financing method that supplies funds based on a company's growth potential and business feasibility, rather than simply relying on collateral. This is closely linked to startup investment, expansion of corporate finance, and support for innovative industries, all of which inherently carry a certain level of risk. This is why Kim emphasized that a bank's "selection capability" in identifying high-quality borrowers is of utmost importance for successful productive finance.


Accordingly, he explained that an incentive system must be established so that loan officers within banks are sufficiently motivated to identify "promising saplings"—companies with growth potential. He stressed, "Because loan officers often rely on soft information and subjective judgment that is difficult to quantify, it is challenging for the organization to assess the level of effort at an institutional level. Therefore, performance-based incentives are essential to mitigate agent problems caused by information asymmetry."


He further argued that once such a system is in place, inappropriate loans will be filtered out, and funds will be allocated to borrowers with high growth potential, thereby enhancing the efficiency of resource allocation and overall productivity of the economy. This represents a shift from finance that merely manages money safely to finance that fosters economic growth. He said, "Productive finance will serve as an opportunity for domestic banks to move away from the traditional, collateral-based 'easy finance' and transition to higher-risk, higher-return business operations based on a company's business feasibility and growth potential."


He also argued that banks should be entitled to recognize results achieved in corporate finance—despite bearing high risks and costs—as legitimate profits. He stated that it is not desirable to mandate that banks reinvest such profits into productive finance simply because those profits were earned under the influence of government policy.


Conversely, he said that if performance is poor, the principle of self-responsibility should be strictly applied. Supporting underperforming banks with public funds, such as tax money, can create a structure where the private sector reaps the rewards of success while society bears the costs of failure. He emphasized that since productive finance is inherently an area predicated on private risk, a system must be established that ensures not only rewards for performance but also that losses are borne independently.


He predicted that once this structure is established, significant changes in the banking landscape will be inevitable. Kim said, "Currently, the business structures and performances of banks are similar, but as productive finance expands, the performance gap will widen according to each bank's risk assessment capabilities. In the future, the differences in competitiveness among banks are likely to become even more pronounced."



He also pointed out that, despite the importance of productive finance, it may be difficult for it to become a policy priority if overshadowed by external factors such as war.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing