Abolishing Prosecutorial Oversight:

5,995 Special Judicial Police Officers in 17 Local Governments under Direct Local Control

83% Are Grade 6 or Below, Centered on Practical Staff

Concerns over Trial and Error amid Lack of Investigat

Concerns Over Local Government Heads Without Legal Backgrounds Directing Investigations [Unleashed Special Judicial Police] ③ View original image

The most concerning aspect if the Prosecution Office Act passes on March 20 is that it could become difficult to control excessive investigations carried out by local government heads using special judicial police officers (special judicial police). In particular, with the traditional system of prosecutorial supervision over special judicial police investigations disappearing, the 5,995 special judicial police officers working in 17 local governments (as of 2024) will now operate according to the internal command chains of their respective municipalities. Until now, prosecutors have been involved from the earliest stages of an investigation, helping to determine its direction. In many cases, if a case was deemed unlikely to constitute a crime during the preliminary investigation, it was closed early. However, without prosecutorial supervision, this "filtering function" will no longer operate, making trial and error in the case handling process inevitable.


According to the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office on March 20, only 24% of local government special judicial police officers have more than two years of continuous service as of 2024. This is a much lower level of experience compared to the 76% figure for special judicial police officers in central government agencies. The composition of ranks is also focused on working-level staff: those in grades 6 through 8 make up 83% of the total, with grade 6 accounting for 36%, grade 7 for 29%, and grade 8 for 19%. Many are rotational civil servants, making it difficult to accumulate investigative experience. In reality, they have relied on the legal review of prosecutors for key procedures such as warrant applications and evidence assessments.


If there is a gap in investigative supervision, considerable confusion may arise in field operations. There is also the risk that the intentions of local government heads could influence investigations. If a local government head, who holds authority over the organization and personnel, concentrates special judicial police officers in a particular area, it becomes possible to effectively plan the direction of investigations. The command and supervisory relationships within the administrative organization can be directly reflected in the handling of criminal cases.


Concerns Over Local Government Heads Without Legal Backgrounds Directing Investigations [Unleashed Special Judicial Police] ③ View original image

For example, if an administrative official, rather than a legal professional, directs the course of an investigation, there is a risk that broad instructions such as "handle this case in this way" could be issued, rather than concrete legal judgments. A legal expert noted, "In the most extreme scenario, a local government head could order an investigation targeting a specific company or organization, or use special judicial police for political purposes such as fulfilling campaign pledges. In such cases, administrative power in the region could, in effect, exercise judicial functions as well." A prosecutor with experience in supervising special judicial police commented, "Going forward, cases could be handled according to the judgment of local government heads or senior officials, increasing the risk that criminal cases will be dealt with as an extension of administrative authority."



There are also concerns that the introduction of the ‘crime of legal distortion’ would make special judicial police officers in local governments directly responsible for legal violations during investigations, leading to an aversion to handling investigations. This is because general civil servants without criminal law expertise could be penalized for mistakenly applying for warrants. One chief prosecutor said, "The burden of the crime of legal distortion and abuse of authority will inevitably cause confusion in practical matters such as warrant applications."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing