Skipping Public Debate and Circulating in the Media
Palace Politics Driven by “Myung-sim” Must Be Avoided

[Inside Chodong] The Perils of "the President's Intention" in Politics View original image

One of the most problematic forms of rhetoric in Korean politics is the phrase "the president's intention." This phrase is usually presented without any further explanation. Instead of discussing why something is necessary, what would be better, or how it would benefit the public, this single phrase is used to shut down debate. It is a way of cloaking an argument in authority rather than supporting it with reasoning. Although "the president's intention" may sound forceful, it often serves as the language of easy politics that skips over genuine argumentation.


The recent controversy over the so-called "prosecutorial indictment withdrawal deal" in connection with prosecution reform illustrated this point. The comments made on YouTube by Kim Eo-jun, one of the leading voices of the ruling bloc, were likely intended to stress that "there must be no compromise with prosecutors" regarding supplementary investigative powers for the Prosecutors’ Office. However, contrary to these intentions, the fallout took the opposite direction. The debate quickly shifted to political wrangling over questions such as "Who was the close aide who conveyed the president's intention to the prosecutors?" and "Was the president's intention connected to the withdrawal of his own indictment?" As the controversy intensified, Hong Ikpyo, Senior Presidential Secretary for Political Affairs, attempted to defuse the situation, calling it "highly inappropriate fake news that could erode public trust in the government." The Democratic Party of Korea ultimately decided to file a complaint. In the end, President Lee Jaemyung, unable to tolerate the situation further, felt compelled to intervene at the Cabinet meeting on the 17th, expressing regret over the unnecessary controversy that had arisen during the process of creating the ruling party-government-presidential office prosecution reform plan, and stating, "Didn't I say to deliberate? We need to talk openly, even to the point of exhaustion," in an effort to resolve the dispute.


Similar controversies have persisted. Most recently, in January, there was the debate over the proposed merger between the Democratic Party of Korea and the Innovation Party led by Cho Kuk. The focus of the debate should have been on the necessity and procedure of the merger, as well as strategies for the upcoming local elections. However, actual political discourse quickly devolved into arguments over whether there had been communication with the presidential office and whether the move carried the president's explicit intent. The so-called "explicit intent SNS" controversy involving Democratic Party Supreme Council member Kang Deukgu led Chief of Staff Kang Hunsik to urge caution when speaking on behalf of the president's intentions, while the presidential office was forced to clarify that "the merger is a matter for the two parties to decide; the presidential office has neither discussed nor taken any position on it." Thus, "the president's intention" ended up circulating in the political sphere as a greater asset than the actual debate over the merger itself.


There is a long-standing habit in Korean politics of regarding those who can accurately read the president's intention as competent politicians. This could well be described as a remnant of court politics. After all, it relieves politicians of the burden of explaining why they are right or persuading their opponents through logic. Such convenient politics often prioritize personal gain and typically lead to regressive outcomes. The essence of policy becomes blurred, trust within the party is eroded, and the president is used up as someone whose name is borrowed for words he never actually spoke.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Politicians should not be people who read the president's intention, but rather those who read the demands of the people. This is especially true for politicians belonging to the ruling party. They must implement the principles they have set forth with the president in terms that the public can relate to, and, if necessary, persuade the other side as well. In "Politics as a Vocation," Max Weber argued that what politicians need is not only conviction but also an ethic of responsibility for the consequences of their actions. In light of this long-standing principle, the president's intention is nothing more than a rhetorical device that should be avoided.



President Lee has said he wants to be remembered as a president who receives praise and love from the people. The path forward is clear: to avoid politics that trade in the president's intention. Democratic politics become healthier through public discourse, not intentions; through persuasion, not authority. The moment politics puts "intention" ahead, claiming to act for the president, politics is diminished and trust in the president declines. Both the president's will and the power of policy are meaningful only within the responsibility of "Is it beneficial to the people?"


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing