Hongseon Kim, Advisor at Kim & Chang and Former Deputy President of Standard Chartered Korea, Raises Concerns

Audience Also Criticizes the Industry: "Include Key Information Such as Security Training Results in Underwriting Questionnaires"

"The issue of cyber insurance underwriting must be resolved by the insurers themselves. It should not be outsourced to security firms or other external providers. Isn't underwriting about assessing risks and pricing them appropriately?"


On the 19th, a panel discussion took place at the Korea Economic Research Association Conference Center in Yeouido, Seoul, during the international seminar "Normalization of Cyber Risks, Challenges and Response Strategies in the Insurance Industry" jointly hosted by the Korea Insurance Research Institute, Assemblyman Lee Dong-soo of the Democratic Party, and Pohang University of Science and Technology. From left to right: Hongseon Kim, Advisor at the Kim & Chang Law Firm; Taehwan Park, Head of the AhnLab Cybersecurity Center (ACSC); Jaehee Son, Director of Consumer Digital Research at the Korea Insurance Research Institute; Kwangmin Jeong, Associate Professor at the Department of Industrial and Management Engineering, Pohang University of Science and Technology; Sie Lau, Head of Cyber at Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance; Kwanghee Choi, Advisor at Sejong Law Firm; Yongmin Choi, Vice President of Prosis Underwriting Solutions. Photo by Chaeseok Moon

On the 19th, a panel discussion took place at the Korea Economic Research Association Conference Center in Yeouido, Seoul, during the international seminar "Normalization of Cyber Risks, Challenges and Response Strategies in the Insurance Industry" jointly hosted by the Korea Insurance Research Institute, Assemblyman Lee Dong-soo of the Democratic Party, and Pohang University of Science and Technology. From left to right: Hongseon Kim, Advisor at the Kim & Chang Law Firm; Taehwan Park, Head of the AhnLab Cybersecurity Center (ACSC); Jaehee Son, Director of Consumer Digital Research at the Korea Insurance Research Institute; Kwangmin Jeong, Associate Professor at the Department of Industrial and Management Engineering, Pohang University of Science and Technology; Sie Lau, Head of Cyber at Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance; Kwanghee Choi, Advisor at Sejong Law Firm; Yongmin Choi, Vice President of Prosis Underwriting Solutions. Photo by Chaeseok Moon

View original image

At an insurance industry seminar, there was a strong call for insurers to accumulate cyber incident data and build their own underwriting capabilities. Because cyber risks are difficult to estimate in terms of probability and damage, and because they often occur simultaneously and in a connected manner, insurers have been taking a highly conservative approach to the underwriting process. The message was that insurers must overcome these limitations on their own.


Hongseon Kim, Advisor at Kim & Chang Law Firm (former Deputy President of Standard Chartered Korea and former CEO of AhnLab), stated at the international seminar on cyber insurance held on March 19, 2026, at the Korea Economic Association Conference Center in Yeouido, Seoul, co-hosted by the Korea Insurance Research Institute, Congressman Yudongsoo of the Democratic Party, and Pohang University of Science and Technology, "Cyber incidents should be viewed not merely as security issues, but as matters that determine whether a 'business' can continue to operate."


Kim pointed out, "Financial institutions assess three types of risk: market, credit, and operational. Cyber risk is a representative operational risk, and under the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) standards, it is reflected in the risk-weighted (RW) portion of the capital adequacy ratio. Korean financial institutions, however, do not assess operational risk based on their own accumulated data, but instead follow regulatory guidelines provided by the financial authorities."


He further explained, "Unlike in Korea, overseas financial institutions take responsibility for addressing cyber risks either independently or through third parties if supervisory agencies deem the risk to be high. Since an increase in RW and the BIS ratio limits lending and business operations, executives and board members cannot afford to remain passive."


He added, "The criteria for determining risks should be the business impact, not regulatory requirements. If not, no matter how stringent the regulations, executives will not address cyber risks properly. To resolve this through management rather than regulation, insurers must measure risks and price them appropriately in the underwriting process, rather than outsourcing to security firms."


Jaehee Sohn, Director of the Consumer Digital Research Division at the Korea Insurance Research Institute, argued that instead of sharing cyber risk-related information only among insurers, authorities should provide incentives for information sharing, such as allowing data to be shared anonymously.


Sohn said, "Even if data is collected, it is mostly historical data, so it is questionable how helpful it will be in the cyber insurance underwriting process. Considering privacy issues, it would be better for the authorities to allow anonymous data sharing and provide incentives for information provision, as well as to establish a reliable and neutral data repository, rather than having insurers share data among themselves."


There was also an opinion that it is premature for the insurance sector to fully adopt AI-based cyber insurance underwriting.


Kim commented, "It is still too early for the insurance industry to apply AI to cyber insurance underwriting. Especially, if physical AI becomes common, the impact of using AI to manage cyber insurance risks will be significant."


He added, "Large language models (LLMs) use neural networks distributed across parameters and store information as filters, rather than simply storing personal data. Through AI inference, it is necessary to determine what constitutes personal information, but there will be confusion about which portion of leaked information should be considered personal data, and there is currently a lack of related security measures."


During the Q&A session, an audience member pointed out that simply strengthening information security disclosures would not be sufficient to reduce cyber risks.


A head of information security at a mid-sized company, who introduced himself as having a credit rating agency background, suggested, "To enhance corporate security, the interest of the CEO must be engaged. Expanding information security disclosures, as the panel suggested, is not enough. If credit rating agency analysts include information security-related factors in their evaluation systems when assigning corporate credit ratings, it will directly affect the company's lending limits and thus encourage CEOs to pay attention to security."



He added, "It would also be effective if insurers transparently disclose key information, such as the results of security training and the negotiation process for ransomware claims, by entering into business agreements with private information firms. I wonder if the panelists are also considering these approaches."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing