430 Cases from KCTU, 189 from FKTU, and Others
Only 13 Principal Contractors Have Announced Negotiation Requests
"Improvements Needed to Minimize Confusion on the Ground"

Just nine days after the implementation of the Yellow Envelope Act (amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Trade Union Act), nearly 700 subcontractors have demanded negotiations with their principal contractors. The labor union's call for the "real employer to come forward" is rapidly spreading beyond the automobile, shipbuilding, and construction sectors to include courier services, cleaning and security service industries, as well as the public sector.

Nine Days After Yellow Envelope Act... 683 Unions in Auto, Construction, and Courier Sectors Demand "Real Employer to Come Forward" (Comprehensive) View original image

According to data submitted by Assemblyman Kim Hyungdong of the People Power Party, who obtained the information from the Ministry of Employment and Labor on March 19, since the law went into effect on March 10, a total of 683 subcontractor unions, branches, and chapters have made negotiation requests against 287 principal contractor worksites. The number of union members included in these negotiation requests totals 127,019.


The Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) accounted for the largest portion of these negotiation requests, with 430 cases. The Korean Metal Workers’ Union has requested negotiations with Hyundai Motor, Hyundai Mobis, HD Hyundai Heavy Industries, Hanwha Ocean, and GM Korea, among others, while the Construction Industry Union has made similar demands to Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Hyundai Engineering.


In addition, the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU) made 189 negotiation requests, and non-affiliated unions submitted 64 requests.


The negotiation requests are rapidly spreading across a wide range of industries. For instance, courier worker unions have directly requested negotiations with principal companies such as CJ Logistics, Hanjin, and Lotte Global Logistics.


On March 19, contract workers responsible for cleaning, security, facilities, and parking management at 15 universities in Seoul also demanded principal-level negotiations with the universities.


Furthermore, 241 KCTU-affiliated and 5 FKTU-affiliated subcontractor unions have requested negotiations with public sector workplaces, including local governments and public institutions.


However, it is understood that only a small number of principal contractors have actually initiated the negotiation process. When a subcontractor union makes a negotiation request, the principal contractor is required to publicly announce this and begin the process of unifying the negotiation channels.


In reality, it is reported that only 13 worksites—including Hanwha Ocean, POSCO, CoupangCLS, Busan Transportation Corporation, and Hwaseong City—have actually initiated these procedures.


Assemblyman Kim stated, "The remaining 274 principal contractor worksites appear to be experiencing confusion, having either not decided whether to negotiate or having failed to establish concrete response measures."


As a result, it is pointed out that most of these cases will likely need to go through deliberations by the Labor Relations Commission or the courts.


In fact, the Labor Relations Commission has already received a total of 10 cases related to "employer determination," which seeks clarification on whether the principal contractor is the actual employer. These cases involve subcontractor unions requesting such a determination on the grounds that the principal contractor has not responded to negotiation requests.



Assemblyman Kim commented, "Although the number of negotiation requests surged in a short period, the rate at which these lead to actual negotiations is very low due to the Ministry of Employment and Labor's lack of preparation and system design. Institutional improvements are needed to minimize confusion on the ground."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing