[Reporter’s Notebook] Is the Fair Trade Commission Truly "Fair"? View original image

"I can't remember the last time a case was dismissed without charge at the Fair Trade Commission stage. Because the Fair Trade Commission's review structure is not fair, it can only be rectified once it reaches the courts."


Recently, a fair trade specialist attorney at a law firm explained the background behind the Fair Trade Commission repeatedly losing lawsuits over administrative fines imposed on companies. The total amount of surcharge interest—the effective interest paid back to companies by the Fair Trade Commission—reached approximately 18.8 billion won over the past five years. Surcharge interest refers to the de facto interest paid along with the principal when a company, after paying an administrative fine, receives a cancellation or reduction through an administrative lawsuit. This means that taxpayers’ money has been wasted due to the wrongful imposition of fines.


Why does the Fair Trade Commission consistently lose in court? One of the main reasons is considered to be its structural problems. The process of imposing fines by the Fair Trade Commission follows a quasi-judicial procedure. After the Commission issues a decision, if a company files a lawsuit, the case goes directly to the High Court, which effectively serves as the court of first instance. However, a closer look at the review structure of the Commission raises questions about fairness. Both the "case examiner" and "commissioner," who play the roles of prosecutor and judge, respectively, are members of the Fair Trade Commission. The process of examiners and commissioners from the same organization deliberating and making decisions on cases is far from securing impartiality.


Has the collegial system designed to ensure fairness lost its effectiveness? The Fair Trade Commission makes decisions by majority vote through meetings among its nine commissioners, including the chairperson. Five standing commissioners, including the chairperson, and four non-standing commissioners determine the level of sanctions, such as the imposition of fines or referring cases to the prosecution. However, out of the 17 individuals who served as non-standing commissioners over the 10 years from 2015 to 2024, at least 12 are classified as pro-Commission figures. These are individuals who had previously handled Fair Trade Commission-related work or served as advisers before becoming non-standing commissioners. Considering that all standing commissioners are filled by former Fair Trade Commission officials, concerns are inevitable that the panel will maintain a perspective favoring the Commission.



Although the Fair Trade Commission internally separated investigation and review functions in 2023, dissatisfaction within the field remains. Isn't a structural, not just internal, separation necessary? The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) could serve as a good precedent. The FTC has separate administrative law judges who make initial judgments based on the investigators’ findings. The FTC renders its final decision based on the administrative law judge’s report. Administrative law judges are hired by the central body and appointed following confirmation by Congress, meaning that investigative and adjudicative functions are essentially separated. Another possible solution is to completely remove the first-instance function by entrusting post-investigation decisions directly to the courts. It is time for the Fair Trade Commission to transform into a truly fair institution.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing