Surge in Judicial Review Petitions Prompts Constitutional Court to Consider Abusive Litigation Safeguards

Discussion Underway on Entry Barriers Such as Deposits and Filing Fees

Court Begins Designing Measures in Anticipation of More Dismissa

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

As applications for retrial petitions continue to surge, the Constitutional Court is considering measures to require petitioners to pay a deposit when filing for adjudication in order to prevent the abuse of litigation (frivolous lawsuits).


According to the coverage by The Asia Business Daily on March 18, the Constitutional Court has begun reviewing mechanisms to prevent “frivolous lawsuits” as it prepares to introduce the retrial petition system. Alternatives under consideration to prevent abuse of litigation include requiring deposits, charging filing fees, imposing separate service charges, and levying fines. This is interpreted as an effort to establish “entry barriers” in anticipation that most retrial petition claims may be dismissed without being reviewed on their merits.


Regarding the deposit system, the Constitutional Court plans to examine whether it can be introduced for retrial petitions by reviewing the overall process, including payment and return procedures, statutes of limitations, and whether unclaimed deposits will revert to the state treasury. For the filing fee system, the Court also intends to consider the scope of those required to pay, exemption criteria, and the actual financial burden it would impose.


In addition, the Court will also review the existing abuse-of-litigation prevention mechanisms currently in operation in domestic courts. This includes evaluating the effectiveness of controls such as restrictions on the use of electronic litigation systems and sanctions during enforcement procedures within the judicial process.


The Constitutional Court will further examine potential side effects that could arise from introducing measures to prevent frivolous lawsuits. The intention is to preemptively address risks such as a sharp decline in case filings due to excessive financial burdens or procedural barriers, or a “psychological chilling effect” that may lead individuals to abandon their right to legal remedy.


Meanwhile, according to the Constitutional Court, a total of 70 retrial petition adjudication requests were filed over the six-day period from the first day of implementation, March 12, to March 17. This averages 11.7 cases per day. Considering that the total number of constitutional complaint cases filed last year was 3,066 (an average of about 8.4 per day), there are observations that the rate of retrial petition filings is already surpassing that of traditional constitutional complaints.



Cases that have become social issues are also turning to retrial petitions one after another. “Gujaeyuk,” who was sentenced to three years in prison for intimidation and extortion of YouTuber Jjiyang, has recently announced plans to file a retrial petition through legal representation. In addition, those involved in the bribery case linked to the election campaign of former Ulsan Mayor Song Cheolho, who were found guilty by the Supreme Court last month, filed a retrial petition on March 13. Former Democratic Party lawmaker Yang Moonseok, who lost his seat after being convicted of loan fraud by the Supreme Court on March 12, has also indicated the possibility of filing a retrial petition.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing