Negotiation Power Gap Between Large and Small Businesses
Policy Impact Weakens Further Down the Supply Chain
Suppliers to Foreign Companies Left in the Blind Spot
Political Community Pursues Legislative Improvements; Industry Calls for Stro

Editor's NoteThe National Assembly is introducing various bills to strengthen industrial competitiveness and revitalize businesses. However, just because a law is enacted does not mean it is immediately effective in practice. The Asia Business Daily is examining the practical limitations that arise in the industrial field after the implementation of new systems through its 'Between Legislation and Reality' series, and is taking a closer look at the supplementary tasks facing the political world.

"It is realistically difficult to ask for an increase in supply prices just because our costs have gone up. If the large company suggests holding a new bid, we would have no choice but to participate, even if it means offering a lower price."


[Between Legislation and Reality ①] "Even With Higher Costs, We Can't Speak Up"... Effectiveness of the Supply Price Indexation System in Doubt View original image

An executive at Company A, which supplies semiconductor parts to major corporations such as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, told The Asia Business Daily on the 23rd, "Legally, we have the right to request price adjustments to reflect higher costs, but subcontractors are reluctant to take the initiative due to fears that the business relationship might be severed."


The 'Supply Price Indexation System,' which mandates that supply prices be adjusted if raw material prices fluctuate beyond a certain level, has been fully implemented since 2024. The aim is to improve the structure where small partner companies bear the burden of rising costs. However, there continue to be concerns in the industrial sector that the system is not functioning properly in practice.


The situation is similar in the automotive parts industry. A representative from casting company B said, "Even if a large company raises the prices for first-tier suppliers, there is a 'delivery mishap' as the price increases get passed down to the second and third tiers." He added, "If you ask first-tier suppliers how much the price was raised, they refuse to disclose it, citing business confidentiality. The more issues you raise, the more you get blacklisted and disadvantaged."


He noted, "Large companies like Hyundai Motor have shown some improvements since the system was implemented, but the further down the supply chain you go, the weaker the effect becomes. In particular, suppliers that provide parts to foreign automakers are essentially left out of the system."


The political sector has also moved to introduce supplementary legislation to enhance the effectiveness of the system. The amendments include expanding the indexation to cover energy costs such as electricity and gas, and prohibiting short-term split contracts designed to avoid the indexation system. The law also explicitly prohibits forcing agreements not to apply the indexation system. The revised bill was promulgated in December last year and is set to be implemented this year.


[Between Legislation and Reality ①] "Even With Higher Costs, We Can't Speak Up"... Effectiveness of the Supply Price Indexation System in Doubt View original image

Industry experts argue that rather than simply adding more provisions to the existing law, supplementary legislation should focus on strengthening enforcement to ensure the system works in practice. Because the negotiation structure between large corporations and small businesses is heavily skewed, merely tightening the rules has its limitations.


The biggest limitation of the current system is that it requires subcontractors to raise issues first. Although the law provides for numerous monitoring and sanction mechanisms, such as dispute mediation, supply price adjustment requests, and fact-finding investigations, small and medium-sized enterprises are often reluctant to go public for fear of losing business relationships.


Furthermore, although the law prohibits unfair practices such as forcing agreements not to apply the indexation system, in reality, more indirect forms of pressure are prevalent. These include inducing rebidding to terminate contracts, gradually reducing order volumes, or excluding suppliers from the supply chain during new product development.


There are also criticisms that the scope of exemptions is excessively broad. The current system exempts cases where both parties agree not to apply the indexation, as well as short-term contracts, small-amount transactions, and deals involving micro-enterprises. While regulations to ban split short-term contracts have recently been added, small-amount and micro-enterprise transactions are still outside the system's scope, meaning in practice the system functions only in a limited way between large corporations and first-tier suppliers.



In November last year, Song Jaebong, a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Korea, introduced an amendment to clarify the scope and requirements for administrative measures such as payment orders for supply prices, thereby enhancing the effectiveness of dispute resolution. Assemblyman Song emphasized, "In a structure with significant power imbalances, leaving things entirely to market autonomy will not establish a fair trading order. The government must supplement the institutional framework so it can intervene effectively when necessary."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing